Authors

  • Maxamadalieva G.Z
    Republican Specialized Scientific And Practical Center Of Hematology, Uzbekistan
  • Gulmirzaev J.A.
    Republican Specialized Scientific And Practical Center Of Hematology, Uzbekistan
  • Xamidova F.I.
    Republican Specialized Scientific And Practical Center Of Hematology, Uzbekistan
  • Isxakov E.D.
    Republican Specialized Scientific And Practical Center Of Hematology, Uzbekistan

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.37547/ijmscr/Volume04Issue06-15

Keywords:

Multiple myeloma chemotherapy Turner syndrome

Abstract

A clinical case of a patient with multiple myeloma with Shereshevsky-Turner syndrome was analyzed. The effectiveness of treatment according to the VRD protocol in the first line in the treatment of multiple myeloma with concomitant congenital mutations was assessed. An early relapse of the disease was revealed, requiring polychemotherapy with monoclonal antibodies.


background image

Volume 04 Issue 06-2024

95


International Journal of Medical Sciences And Clinical Research
(ISSN

2771-2265)

VOLUME

04

ISSUE

06

P

AGES

:

95-104

OCLC

1121105677
















































Publisher:

Oscar Publishing Services

Servi

ABSTRACT

A clinical case of a patient with multiple myeloma with Shereshevsky-Turner syndrome was analyzed. The

effectiveness of treatment according to the VRD protocol in the first line in the treatment of multiple myeloma with

concomitant congenital mutations was assessed. An early relapse of the disease was revealed, requiring

polychemotherapy with monoclonal antibodies.

KEYWORDS

Multiple myeloma, chemotherapy, Turner syndrome, chromosome.

INTRODUCTION

Shereshevsky-Turner syndrome is a genetically

determined pathology that develops exclusively in

girls. In this chromosomal disease, the second of the

sex X chromosomes is lost. In some cases, only part of

it is missing. Changes in the chromosome set also

manifest themselves phenotypically (1,5,9,10). The

Research Article

MULTIPLE MYELOMA AND SHERSHEVSKY TERNER'S SYNDROME
(CLINICAL CASE)

Submission Date:

June 20, 2024,

Accepted Date:

June 25, 2024,

Published Date:

June 30, 2024

Crossref doi:

https://doi.org/10.37547/ijmscr/Volume04Issue06-15


Maxamadalieva G.Z.

Republican Specialized Scientific And Practical Center Of Hematology, Uzbekistan

Gulmirzaev J.A.

Republican Specialized Scientific And Practical Center Of Hematology, Uzbekistan

Xamidova F.I.

Republican Specialized Scientific And Practical Center Of Hematology, Uzbekistan

Isxakov E.D.

Republican Specialized Scientific And Practical Center Of Hematology, Uzbekistan


Journal

Website:

https://theusajournals.
com/index.php/ijmscr

Copyright:

Original

content from this work
may be used under the
terms of the creative
commons

attributes

4.0 licence.


background image

Volume 04 Issue 06-2024

96


International Journal of Medical Sciences And Clinical Research
(ISSN

2771-2265)

VOLUME

04

ISSUE

06

P

AGES

:

95-104

OCLC

1121105677
















































Publisher:

Oscar Publishing Services

Servi

prevalence of the anomaly is quite high - 1 case per 2

2.5 thousand newborn girls. The pathology is one of

the three most common genetic diseases along with

Klinefelter syndrome and Down disease (2,7,12).

Shereshevsky-Turner syndrome was described in 1925

by the Soviet endocrinologist N.A. Shereshevsky, who

believed that it was caused by underdevelopment of

the gonads and the anterior pituitary gland and was

combined with congenital malformations of internal

development. In 1938, Turner identified a triad of

symptoms characteristic of this symptom complex:

sexual infantilism, skin pterygoid folds on the lateral

surfaces of the neck and deformation of the elbow

joints (3,4,13). The following chromosomal aberrations

are possible, leading to the STS phenotype:

• X monosomy (45, XO);

• Partial or complete deletion

of the short arm of the

X chromosome (delXp);

• Complete deletion of the long arm of the X

chromosome (delXq);

• Isochromosome of the long arm of the X

chromosome (i (Xq));

• ring X chromosome (r (X));

• marker chromosome (46, X + m);

• mosaicism, that is, the presence of more than two

cell lines in one person, most often 45,X/46,XX and

45,X/46,XY.

Depending on the size of the lesions, clinical symptoms

differ. In cases of mosaicism, the full range of

symptoms may also be absent (1,2,3). Mapping the X

chromosome and studying some of its genes made it

possible to associate some features of TTS with

dysfunction of certain genes. It also turned out that the

variability of the cytogenetic image is expressed in the

variability of the phenotype of patients with STS, which

is important in predicting the course of the disease

(2,7,12,8).

According to the literature, a clear connection

between the occurrence of Shereshevsky-Turner

syndrome and age and any diseases of the parents has

not been identified. In the embryo, primary germ cells

are formed in almost normal numbers, but in the

second half of pregnancy they undergo rapid

involution (reverse development), and by the time the

child is born, the number of follicles in the ovary is

sharply reduced compared to the norm or they are

completely absent. This leads to severe deficiency of

female sex hormones, sexual underdevelopment, and

in most patients to primary amenorrhea (absence of

menstruation) and infertility (6,9,10,13). The resulting

chromosomal abnormalities are the cause of

developmental defects. It is also possible that

concomitant autosomal mutations play a certain role in


background image

Volume 04 Issue 06-2024

97


International Journal of Medical Sciences And Clinical Research
(ISSN

2771-2265)

VOLUME

04

ISSUE

06

P

AGES

:

95-104

OCLC

1121105677
















































Publisher:

Oscar Publishing Services

Servi

the appearance of developmental defects, since there

are conditions similar to Shereshevsky-Turner

syndrome, but without visible chromosomal pathology

and sexual underdevelopment. Other pathological

findings are consistent with the clinical presentation.

The most important changes in the osteoarticular

system are shortening of the metacarpal and

metatarsal bones, aplasia (absence) of the phalanges

of the fingers, deformation of the wrist joint, and

osteoporosis of the vertebrae. Radiologically, in

Shereshevsky-Turner syndrome, the sella turcica and

the bones of the cranial vault are usually not changed

(3,6,8). All regions of the world and culture are

affected by this pathology approximately equally. It is

estimated to occur in 3% of all human fetuses.

However, only 1% of these fetuses survive birth. Normal

skeletal development is inhibited due to a wide variety

of factors, mainly hormonal. The average height of a

woman with STS without growth hormone treatment

is 140 cm. Patients with mosaic STS can reach a normal

average height. Due to insufficient estrogen

production, many people with TTS develop

osteoporosis. This can further reduce height and also

worsen the curvature of the spine, which can lead to

scoliosis. It also leads to an increased risk of bone

fractures (4,6,7,9).

About a third of all women with STS have one of three

kidney pathologies:

• One horseshoe

-shaped kidney on one side of the

div (instead of the usual two)

• Incorrect urine collection system

• Poor blood flow to the kidneys

Some of these conditions can be corrected with

surgery. Even with these abnormalities, the kidneys of

most women with STS function normally. However, as

noted above, kidney problems can be associated with

hypertension.

Approximately one third of all women with TTS have

thyroid

disease

(10,11,

23).

This

is

usually

hypothyroidism, specifically Hashimoto's thyroiditis.

Once detected, it can be easily treated with thyroid

hormones. Women with TTS have a moderately

increased risk of developing diabetes in childhood and

a significantly increased risk of developing diabetes in

adulthood (1,5,7) . A rare type of TTS, known as Ring-X

Turner syndrome, is associated with mental

retardation in 60% of cases. This type accounts for

about 2

4% of all cases of STS (6).

People with TTS are almost always infertile. Although

some women with TTS have successfully conceived

and survived pregnancy, it is very rare and usually

occurs in those women whose karyotype is not 45, X0.

The literature does not describe a case of multiple

myeloma in patients with STS.


background image

Volume 04 Issue 06-2024

98


International Journal of Medical Sciences And Clinical Research
(ISSN

2771-2265)

VOLUME

04

ISSUE

06

P

AGES

:

95-104

OCLC

1121105677
















































Publisher:

Oscar Publishing Services

Servi

Purpose of the study: To analyze a clinical case of a

patient with multiple myeloma with Shereshevsky-

Turner syndrome

Patient V., 45 years old (Russian language teacher)

with Shereshevsky-Turner Syndrome (TST) complete X-

monosomy, was admitted to the Republican

Specialized Scientific and Practical Medical Center of

Hematology with complaints of general weakness,

dizziness, bone pain, decreased appetite, and

palpitations.

Karyotype 45.XO

Symptoms

Frequency by

occurrence %

In

our case

Intelligence preserved

50-60

+

Stunting

98

+

General dysplasticity (abnormal physique)

92

+

Lymphostasis (swelling) of the arms and legs

24

+


background image

Volume 04 Issue 06-2024

99


International Journal of Medical Sciences And Clinical Research
(ISSN

2771-2265)

VOLUME

04

ISSUE

06

P

AGES

:

95-104

OCLC

1121105677
















































Publisher:

Oscar Publishing Services

Servi

Barrel chest and widely spaced nipples

75

+

Neck shortening

63

+

Low hairline at the back of the head

57

-

Low-set ears, ear deformation

46

-

Infertility

100

+

Vestigial ovaries

80-100

+

Amenorrhea

80-100

+

Small nails

60-79

-

Specific facial features

60-79

-

Wing-shaped folds of skin in the neck area

46

+

• Bicuspid aortic valve

50

-

High waist-to-hip ratio (hips not much larger than

waist)

80-100

-

Height below 140 cm.

80-100

160

см

The fourth metacarpal may be unusually short,

as may the fifth.

40-59

+

Osteoporosis and scoliosis.

40-50

+

bone fractures.

-

+


background image

Volume 04 Issue 06-2024

100


International Journal of Medical Sciences And Clinical Research
(ISSN

2771-2265)

VOLUME

04

ISSUE

06

P

AGES

:

95-104

OCLC

1121105677
















































Publisher:

Oscar Publishing Services

Servi

According to the literature on cardiovascular

malformations, complications of aortic dilatation are

usually associated with a 45.X karyotype, but in our

case, no pathology with cardiovascular pathology was

identified.[27].

Survey results:

In the hemogram dated 08/03/23: hemoglobin 52.0 g/l,

erythrocytes 1.70 million, c.p.-0.9, leukocytes 5.83

thousand/μl, platelets 30.0 thousand/μl, p.o.

-6.0, s.o. -

45.0, lymphocytes 45.0 thousand/μl, mon.

-4.0%, ESR-

20mm/hour.

Serum β2

-microglobulin - 14,240.0 ng/mL, LDH - 180 U/l.

Considering the anemic syndrome and bone pain,

immunofixation of pathological serum proteins was

done: M protein was detected, free kappa was

detected 294.33 mg/l.

Test Name

Result

Unit(s)

Biological

reference

interval

Total Protein (Biueret)

7.5

gdL

6.4-8.2

Albumin (Gel Hecfophoresis)

2.72

S/dL

3.57-5.42

Alpha 1 Globutin {Gel

Ebcnrophoresis)

0.14

S/dL

0.19-0.40

Alpha 2 Globutin

0.37

g/dL

0.45-0.96

Beta Globutin

0.45

S/dL

0.30-0.59

Gamma Globulin

3.83

g/dL

0.71-1.54

AlbuminlGlobulin Ratio

0.57

Ratio

1.0-2.2

'M" Band

Present

-

Absent


background image

Volume 04 Issue 06-2024

101


International Journal of Medical Sciences And Clinical Research
(ISSN

2771-2265)

VOLUME

04

ISSUE

06

P

AGES

:

95-104

OCLC

1121105677
















































Publisher:

Oscar Publishing Services

Servi

According to PET-CT data: metabolic active destructive

foci in all bone structures - changes similar to myeloma?

Pleurisy on both sides. Pericarditis.

In the myelogram dated July 25, 2023: The bone

marrow punctate is medium cellular. Hematological

cells - 100 cells are rare, mostly non-hematological cells

- atypical cells are found.

According to MRI: signs of diffuse damage to the bone

marrow of the skeleton. Hepatosplenomegaly.

Bilateral hydrothorax. Anasarka.

According to trephine biopsy data during microscopic

examination: conclusion: histological picture of plasma

cell dyscrasia.

According to FISH data from 11/21/23:

1. 13q deletion (locus 13q14) not detected

2. Deletion of the TP53 gene (kjre 17p13.1) was not

detected.

3. Translocation t(11;14), leading to the formation of a

fusion signal of the IGH::CCTV1 gene. Not found.

4. Translocation t(4;14), leading to the formation of a

fusion signal of the IGH: FGFR3 gene, was not detected.

Thus, the main diagnosis was established: Multiple

myeloma with Kappa light chain secretion. Diffuse-

focal form. Stage IIIA (according to B. Durie, S.

Salmon). ISS III. R-ISS II.

Related: Q96.9 Turner syndrome, unspecified. I89.0

Lymphoedema, not elsewhere classified.


background image

Volume 04 Issue 06-2024

102


International Journal of Medical Sciences And Clinical Research
(ISSN

2771-2265)

VOLUME

04

ISSUE

06

P

AGES

:

95-104

OCLC

1121105677
















































Publisher:

Oscar Publishing Services

Servi

Complication: Diffuse damage to the skeletal bones.

Hepatosplenomegaly. Anasarka. Conducted No. 3 VRD:

From 09.12.23 to 11.23.23 3 courses of PCT "VRD"

(Bortezomib 1.0 mg/m2, Lenalidomide 25 mg/day,

Dexamethasone), Hemotransfusion 3p mark. er. wt.

No. 5.

After the 3rd course of treatment, CR was achieved,

maintenance

therapy

was

prescribed

with

lenalidomide 25 mg orally, but after three months the

disease relapsed, treatment with Daratumumab 16

mg/kg + Pomalide 4 mg + dexamethasone was started.

After two courses, partial remission was achieved.

Discussion: There are no cases of multiple myeloma

with Shereshevsky-Turner syndrome described in the

literature. In our case, the patient was not found to

have pathogenetic mutations that play a role in the

development of multiple myeloma. According to the

authors Smith L, Barlogie B, Alexanian R.Smith L, et al.

biclonal tumors often showed atypical myeloma

protein changes with chemotherapy, suggesting that

one clone was reduced while the other remained

unchanged. These data suggest a genetic basis for the

resistance of low-RNA tumors to chemotherapy,

possibly accounting for early relapse. Based on the

therapy performed, one can judge the effectiveness of

PCT according to the VRD protocol in the first line in the

treatment of multiple myeloma with combined

congenital mutations, but early relapse of the disease

requires

polychemotherapy

with

monoclonal

antibodies.

CONCLUSION

Thus, we can conclude that patients with multiple

myeloma with combined congenital mutations should

be classified as a high-risk group despite the absence of

high-risk cytogenetic abnormalities by FISH. MM with

biclonal proteins should be considered a high-risk

group, although the R-ISS classification does not assess

biclonality.

REFERENCES

1.

Claus

Højbjerg

Gravholt.

Epidemiological,

endocrine and metabolic features in Turner

syndrome // European Journal of Endocrinology.

2004-12.

Т. 151, вып. 6. —

С. 657–

687.

ISSN

0804-4643.

doi:10.1530/eje.0.1510657.

2.

Jay W. Ellison, Zabihullah Wardak, Marian F. Young,

Pamela Gehron Robey, Marion Laig-Webster.

PHOG, a Candidate Gene for Involvement in the

Short Stature of Turner Syndrome (англ.) // Human

Molecular Genetics.

1997-08-01.

Vol. 6, iss. 8.

P. 1341

1347.

ISSN 0964-6906.

doi:10.1093/hmg/6.8.1341.

3.

Mark Clement-Jones, Simone Schiller, Ercole Rao,

Rüdiger J. Blaschke, Aimee Zuniga. The short

stature homeobox gene SHOX is involved in

skeletal abnormalities in Turner syndr

ome (англ.) //

Human Molecular Genetics.

2000-03-22.

Vol.


background image

Volume 04 Issue 06-2024

103


International Journal of Medical Sciences And Clinical Research
(ISSN

2771-2265)

VOLUME

04

ISSUE

06

P

AGES

:

95-104

OCLC

1121105677
















































Publisher:

Oscar Publishing Services

Servi

9, iss. 5.

P. 695

702.

ISSN 0964-6906.

doi:10.1093/hmg/9.5.695.

4.

Catherine A. Boucher, Carole A. Sargent, Tsutomu

Ogata, Nabeel A. Affara. Breakpoint analysis of

Turner patients with partial Xp deletions:

implications for the lymphoedema gene location

(англ.) // Journal of Medical Genetics. —

2001-09-

01.

Vol. 38, iss. 9.

P. 591

598.

ISSN 1468-

6244

0022-2593,

1468-6244.

doi:10.1136/jmg.38.9.591.

Архивировано

21

октября 2020 года.

5.

Endocrine

Press

|

Endocrine

Society.

www.endocrine.org.

6.

Judith L. Ross, David Roeltgen, Harvey Kushner,

Fanglin Wei, Andrew R. Zinn. The Turner

Syndrome

Associated Neurocognitive Phenotype

Maps to Distal Xp // American Journal of Human

Genetics.

2000-9.

Т. 67, вып. 3. —

С. 672–

681.

ISSN 0002-9297.

7.

Constantine Stratakis, Owen Rennert. Turner

Syndrome:

Molecular

and

Cytogenetics,

Dysmorphology, Endocrine, and Other Clinical

Manifestations and Their Management (англ.) //

The Endocrinologist.

1994-11.

Vol. 4, iss. 6.

P.

442

453.

ISSN

1051-2144.

doi:10.1097/00019616-199411000-00007.

8.

INSERM US14-- ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Orphanet:

Perrault syndrome (англ.). www.orpha.net.

9.

Michele Curtis, Leah Antoniewicz, Silvia T. Linares.

Glass' Office Gynecology.

Lippincott Williams &

Wilkins, 2014.

656 с

.

ISBN 978-1-60831-820-9.

10.

Gareth Weston, Beverly Vollenhoven, Jane

McNeilage. Practice OSCEs in Obstetrics &

Gynaecology: A Guide for the Medical Student and

MRANZCOG exams.

Elsevier Health Sciences,

2009-01-05.

249 с. —

ISBN 978-0-7295-7867-7.

11.

Bicuspid

Aortic

Valve:

Background,

Pathophysiology, Epidemiology.

2019-11-10.

12.

Michèle M.M. Mazzocco. The cognitive phenotype

of Turner syndrome: Specific learning disabilities //

International congress series / Excerpta Medica.

2006-10-01.

Т. 1298. —

С. 83–

92.

ISSN 0531-

5131.

doi:10.1016/j.ics.2006.06.016.

13.

Turner syndrome -

Symptoms and causes (англ.).

Mayo Clinic.

14.

Botirovna, N. H., & Munisa, N. (2024). HISTORICAL

STUDY OF EDUCATION AS A NATIONAL VALUES.

International Journal of Advance Scientific

Research, 4(05), 19-21.

15.

Botirovna, N. H. (2024). DEVELOPMENT OF

NATIONAL VALUES IN STUDENTS DISTINCTIVE

FEATURES. Web of Medicine: Journal of Medicine,

Practice and Nursing, 2(1), 1-2.

16.

Botirovna, N. H., & Shukrona, Y. (2024).

PEDAGOGICAL NEEDS OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF

NATIONAL VALUES IN STUDENTS.


background image

Volume 04 Issue 06-2024

104


International Journal of Medical Sciences And Clinical Research
(ISSN

2771-2265)

VOLUME

04

ISSUE

06

P

AGES

:

95-104

OCLC

1121105677
















































Publisher:

Oscar Publishing Services

Servi

17.

Botirovna, N. H. (2022). SYSTEMATIC METHODS OF

DEVELOPMENT OF NATIONAL VALUES IN

STUDENTS

18.

Nurbaeva H. B., Mirzaev B. U. O. ABU RAYHON

MUHAMMAD IBN AHMAD AL-BYERUNIY YOSHLAR

TARBIYASIDAGI AHAMIYATI //Academic research

in educational sciences.

2022.

№. 3. –

С. 107

-113.

19.

Nurbaeva, Habiba Botrovna, and O‘Rolov

Muxammadqodir. "MILLIY QADRIYATLAR HAR BIR

MILLATNING O ‘TMISHI, BUGUNI VA KELAJAGI."

Academic research in educational sciences 3

(2022): 195-197

20.

Botirovna, N. H., & Munisa, N. (2024). HISTORICAL

STUDY OF EDUCATION AS A NATIONAL VALUES.

International Journal of Advance Scientific

Research, 4(05), 19-21.

References

Claus Højbjerg Gravholt. Epidemiological, endocrine and metabolic features in Turner syndrome // European Journal of Endocrinology. — 2004-12. — Т. 151, вып. 6. — С. 657–687. — ISSN 0804-4643. — doi:10.1530/eje.0.1510657.

Jay W. Ellison, Zabihullah Wardak, Marian F. Young, Pamela Gehron Robey, Marion Laig-Webster. PHOG, a Candidate Gene for Involvement in the Short Stature of Turner Syndrome (англ.) // Human Molecular Genetics. — 1997-08-01. — Vol. 6, iss. 8. — P. 1341–1347. — ISSN 0964-6906. — doi:10.1093/hmg/6.8.1341.

Mark Clement-Jones, Simone Schiller, Ercole Rao, Rüdiger J. Blaschke, Aimee Zuniga. The short stature homeobox gene SHOX is involved in skeletal abnormalities in Turner syndrome (англ.) // Human Molecular Genetics. — 2000-03-22. — Vol. 9, iss. 5. — P. 695–702. — ISSN 0964-6906. — doi:10.1093/hmg/9.5.695.

Catherine A. Boucher, Carole A. Sargent, Tsutomu Ogata, Nabeel A. Affara. Breakpoint analysis of Turner patients with partial Xp deletions: implications for the lymphoedema gene location (англ.) // Journal of Medical Genetics. — 2001-09-01. — Vol. 38, iss. 9. — P. 591–598. — ISSN 1468-6244 0022-2593, 1468-6244. — doi:10.1136/jmg.38.9.591. Архивировано 21 октября 2020 года.

Endocrine Press | Endocrine Society. www.endocrine.org.

Judith L. Ross, David Roeltgen, Harvey Kushner, Fanglin Wei, Andrew R. Zinn. The Turner Syndrome–Associated Neurocognitive Phenotype Maps to Distal Xp // American Journal of Human Genetics. — 2000-9. — Т. 67, вып. 3. — С. 672–681. — ISSN 0002-9297.

Constantine Stratakis, Owen Rennert. Turner Syndrome: Molecular and Cytogenetics, Dysmorphology, Endocrine, and Other Clinical Manifestations and Their Management (англ.) // The Endocrinologist. — 1994-11. — Vol. 4, iss. 6. — P. 442–453. — ISSN 1051-2144. — doi:10.1097/00019616-199411000-00007.

INSERM US14-- ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Orphanet: Perrault syndrome (англ.). www.orpha.net.

Michele Curtis, Leah Antoniewicz, Silvia T. Linares. Glass' Office Gynecology. — Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, 2014. — 656 с. — ISBN 978-1-60831-820-9.

Gareth Weston, Beverly Vollenhoven, Jane McNeilage. Practice OSCEs in Obstetrics & Gynaecology: A Guide for the Medical Student and MRANZCOG exams. — Elsevier Health Sciences, 2009-01-05. — 249 с. — ISBN 978-0-7295-7867-7.

Bicuspid Aortic Valve: Background, Pathophysiology, Epidemiology. — 2019-11-10.

Michèle M.M. Mazzocco. The cognitive phenotype of Turner syndrome: Specific learning disabilities // International congress series / Excerpta Medica. — 2006-10-01. — Т. 1298. — С. 83–92. — ISSN 0531-5131. — doi:10.1016/j.ics.2006.06.016.

Turner syndrome - Symptoms and causes (англ.). Mayo Clinic.

Botirovna, N. H., & Munisa, N. (2024). HISTORICAL STUDY OF EDUCATION AS A NATIONAL VALUES. International Journal of Advance Scientific Research, 4(05), 19-21.

Botirovna, N. H. (2024). DEVELOPMENT OF NATIONAL VALUES IN STUDENTS DISTINCTIVE FEATURES. Web of Medicine: Journal of Medicine, Practice and Nursing, 2(1), 1-2.

Botirovna, N. H., & Shukrona, Y. (2024). PEDAGOGICAL NEEDS OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF NATIONAL VALUES IN STUDENTS.

Botirovna, N. H. (2022). SYSTEMATIC METHODS OF DEVELOPMENT OF NATIONAL VALUES IN STUDENTS

Nurbaeva H. B., Mirzaev B. U. O. ABU RAYHON MUHAMMAD IBN AHMAD AL-BYERUNIY YOSHLAR TARBIYASIDAGI AHAMIYATI //Academic research in educational sciences. – 2022. – №. 3. – С. 107-113.

Nurbaeva, Habiba Botrovna, and O‘Rolov Muxammadqodir. "MILLIY QADRIYATLAR HAR BIR MILLATNING O ‘TMISHI, BUGUNI VA KELAJAGI." Academic research in educational sciences 3 (2022): 195-197

Botirovna, N. H., & Munisa, N. (2024). HISTORICAL STUDY OF EDUCATION AS A NATIONAL VALUES. International Journal of Advance Scientific Research, 4(05), 19-21.