Авторы

  • Муяссарзода Файзиева
    ассистент кафедры Управления Человеческими Ресурсами, Ташкентский государственный экономический университет, Ташкент, Узбекистан
  • Мария Бекимбетова
    студент MBA, Бинарная Высшая школа, Ташкентский финансовый институт, Ташкент, Узбекистан

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.47689/2181-1415-vol2-iss8/S-pp102-110

Ключевые слова:

Первый Ренессанс Второй Ренессанс Третий Ренессанс наука научная деятельность научное исследование просвещение

Аннотация

Данная статья посвящена вопросу применения науки в построении фундамента Третьего Ренессанса в Узбекистане с акцентом на развитие науки в период Первого и Второго Ренессансов в Центральной Азии. В данном исследовании были изучены принятые за последние годы законодательные и нормативные документы в области науки и научной деятельности в Узбекистане, а также обобщены работы, проделанные в данной сфере за предыдущие годы.


background image

Жамият ва инновациялар –

Общество и инновации –

Society and innovations

Journal home page:

https://inscience.uz/index.php/socinov/index

The progress of science in Uzbekistan – the foundation of the
third renaissance

Muyassarzoda FAYZIEVA

1

Mariya BEKIMBETOVA

2


Tashkent State University of Economics
Tashkent Institute of Finance

ARTICLE INFO

ABSTRACT

Article history:

Received July 2021
Received in revised form
20 July 2021
Accepted 15 August 2021
Available online
15 September 2021

This research paper is devoted to the issue of applying science

in building the foundation of the Third Renaissance in
Uzbekistan with a focus on developed science fields in Central
Asia during the First and Second Renaissances. In this research,
the recent legislative and scientific activities in Uzbekistan were
studied and the previous work performed in the field of science
in the past years was summarized as a basis for writing this
paper.

2181-1415/© 2021 in Science LLC.
This is an open access article under the Attribution 4.0 International
(CC BY 4.0) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.ru)

Keywords:

the first renaissance,
the second renaissance,
the third renaissance,
science,
scientific activity,
scientific research,
enlightenment.

O‘zbekistonda ilm-fanning taraqqiyoti – uchinchi renessans
poydevori

ANNOTATSIYA

Kalit so‘zlar:

birinchi renessans,
ikkinchi renessans,
uchinchi renessans,
ilm-fan,
ilmiy faoliyat,
ilmiy tadqiqot,
ma’rifat.

Ushbu maqola Birinchi va Ikkinchi Renessans davrlarida O‘rta

Osiyo hududida rivojlanib taraqqiy etgan ilm-fanni diqqat
markazda tutgan holda O‘zbekistonda Uchinchi Renessans
poydevorini qurishda aynan ilm-fanga murojaat etish masalasiga
bag‘ishlangan. Ushbu tadqiqotda O‘zbekistonda so‘nggi yillarda
qabul qilingan ilm-fan va ilmiy faoliyatga tegishli qonun
hujjatlari o‘rganildi va o‘tgan yillarda amalga oshirilgan ilm-
fanga tegishli ishlar sarhisob qilindi.

1

Assistant of the Human Resource Management department, Tashkent State University of Economics, Tashkent,

Uzbekistan.
E-mail: fayzievamuyassar87@gmail.com.

2

MBA student, Binary Graduate School, Tashkent Institute of Finance, Tashkent, Uzbekistan.

E-mail: mariya.bekim@gmail.com.


background image

Жамият ва инновациялар – Общество и инновации – Society and innovations

Special Issue – 8 (2021) / ISSN 2181-1415

103

Прогресс науки в Узбекистане – основа третьего ренессанса

АННОТАЦИЯ

Ключевые слова:

первый ренессанс,
второй ренессанс,
третий ренессанс,
наука, научная
деятельность,
научное исследование,
просвещение.

Данная статья посвящена вопросу применения науки в

построении фундамента Третьего Ренессанса в Узбекистане
с акцентом на развитие науки в период Первого и Второго
Ренессансов в Центральной Азии. В данном исследовании
были

изучены

принятые

за

последние

годы

законодательные и нормативные документы в области
науки и научной деятельности в Узбекистане, а также
обобщены работы, проделанные в данной сфере за
предыдущие годы.


INTRODUCTION
The word of the Third Renaissance began to be spoken in the fourth quarter of

2020 and continued in Uzbekistan for several months. It is not difficult to realize here that
it is time to think and implement the act of the Third Renaissance after the First and Second
Renaissances in Central Asia. If we look back to history, we may see that we are a bit late
to starting the Third Renaissance as there is already a five-century gap between the
previous ones. The president of the Republic of Uzbekistan, Sh. Mirziyoyev, spoke about
the Third Renaissance at the governmental ceremonies, thereby assuring the relevance of
this topic at the government level. President Sh. Mirziyoyev pays great attention to the
development of natural and fundamental sciences. Therefore, it is a huge boost to the
foundation of the Third Renaissance in Uzbekistan. The First Renaissance took place in the
period of the Samanid dynasty in the IXth-XIIth centuries, and the Second Renaissance in
the period of the Timurid dynasty in the last quarter of the XIVth and the first quarter of
the XVIth centuries.

Generally speaking, five centuries have passed since then, and we have to build a

foundation for the Third Renaissance. In this research paper, we attempted to justify the
view that science is the most significant pillar for building the foundation of the Third
Renaissance. In recent years, there has been an increasing interest in engaging in science,
especially among adults and young people. Several legislative documents have been signed
in recent years aimed at progressing science and, at the same time, at supporting aspirants
to create a basis for scientific activities in Uzbekistan.

Science from the Latin word scientia, means “knowledge, a knowing; expertness”

[1, Online Etymology Dictionary, “S”]. Modern science is commonly divided into three
major branches: natural science, social science, and formal science. Each of these branches
comprise of various specialized, yet, overlapping scientific disciplines that often possess
their own nomenclature and expertise [2]. There is no doubt that two Renaissances
occurred due to the development of science in Central Asia, and at the same time,
enlightenment also prospered. The progress of science and enlightenment can be linked
with the spread of Islam in Central Asia.

At the initiative of Caliph Harun al-Rashid, a scientific Center-Academy (“Bayt

ul-Hikma”) was established in Baghdad, which brought together scholars from all Muslim
countries, including Central Asian countries. Scholars from Movaraunnahr and Khorasan,
such as Musa al-Khorezmi, Ahmad al-Farghani, Marwazi, Marwarudi, and Jawhari, have
made a significant contribution to making the Baghdad Academy highly recognizable on a


background image

Жамият ва инновациялар – Общество и инновации – Society and innovations

Special Issue – 8 (2021) / ISSN 2181-1415

104

world scale. One of the positive aspects of the establishment of the Arab caliphate in
Movaraunnahr and the spread of Islam was the forming of the Mamun Academy in
Khorezm in the 10th century. The most respected figures and Hadith scholars of the
Islamic world have graduated from the Mamun Academy in our country [3]. The
foundation of the modern palace of science was the result of the great and universal
activities of the Muslims ummah [4, P. 219]. If we learn biographies of the scholars, we
identify that these great and unique scholars knew of Islam history and had Islamic
knowledge. For example, “Ibn Sina memorized of the Qur’an and other several religious
books under the age of ten” [4, P. 221]. The relationship between science and Islam is
subject to endless debates and still stays as controversial. In the Muslim world, many
believe that modern science was first developed in the Muslim world rather than Europe
and Western countries, that “all the wealth of knowledge in the world has actually
emanated from Muslim civilization” and what people call “the scientific method”, is
actually “the Islamic method” [5, Academic dictionaries and Encyclopedias]. It is clear that
great and famous scholars are immortal with their works and scientific discoveries. These
days, we enjoy all of the treasures of knowledge that was accumulated by these scholars
and used and transmitted by our ancestors from one generation to another. These works
had an impact not only on the East enlightenment, as well as on the enlightenment of the
West as well.

From the article, readers can learn that the people of the East experienced the

Renaissance before the Europeans, and discover the opportunities created by our
government for the development of science, and learn some recommendations for
reinforcement of science and scientific activities between students and other participants
in the society of Uzbekistan.

The purpose of this research is to study the importance of science in the First and

Second Renaissances and to offer several recommendations that affect positively the start
of the foundation of the Third Renaissance in Uzbekistan.


MAIN PART
The concept of “Renaissance” is a French word and it means “rebirth”. The meaning

of this term is very broad: in culture, in science, in art, in education, in general, it means
that, after a long period of stagnation in the life of society, the system of values will enter a
new qualitative stage. The concept of “Renaissance” was used for the first time in the
development period in Europe in between the XVth and XVIth centuries. But after the
publication of the book "Muslim Renaissance" in 1909 by the famous Australian orientalist
Adam Metz, it became clear that the Renaissance was not a European phenomenon. On the
contrary, the people of the East experienced the Renaissance earlier than Europeans.

The Great Russian orientalist academician Conrad emphasized that the Renaissance

begun in China in the VIIth-VIIIth centuries, it continued in India in the VIIIth century,
thereafter it passed to the Islam countries in the IXth–XIIth centuries, due to the Mongol
invasion it flourished again during Amir Temur and the Temurids period. According to
Linda Darling, in the past, the term “renaissance” was used in connection with high-
cultural developments under two Middle Eastern regimes, the Buyids (945–1055) and the
Timurids (1370–1506). A re-examination of the dynamics of these two developments
should help to restore a sense of this region as an active partner in worldwide cultural
development and of the interconnectedness of the premodern world [6, P. 56]. When the


background image

Жамият ва инновациялар – Общество и инновации – Society and innovations

Special Issue – 8 (2021) / ISSN 2181-1415

105

Renaissance shifted to Europe in the XVth century the region of Central Asia had seen two
times of the Renaissance periods (IX–XII, XIV–XVI). Al-Farghani, Al-Khorezmiy, Al-Farabi,
Abu Reikhan Beruniy, Abu Ali ibn Sina (Avicenna), Yusuf Khass Hajib, Mahmud al-
Kashgari, Mahmud al-Zamakhshari, great Hadith Scholars Imam al-Bukhari, Imam at-
Tirmidhi, Imam An-Nasaiy, mutakallims Abu Mansur al-Maturidi, Abu al-Mu’in al-Nasafi,
Islamic jurist (it is called in uzbek language “fiqh”) Burhanuddin al-Marginani, scholar
Nizamulmulk and others have highlighted with new sciences of the whole world since IXth
century. During the Second Renaissance, scholars Qazizoda Rumi, MirzoUlugbek, Jamshid
al-Kashi, Ali Qushji, classical poets and thinkers Lutfi, Sakkoki, Hafiz Khorezmi,
Abdurakhmon Jami, Alisher Navaiy, Zahiruddin Muhammad Babur, historians Sharaf ad-
Din Ali Yazdi, Mirkhand, Khandamir, artists Mahmud Muzahhib, Kemaleddin Behzad, as
well as many calligraphers and musicians, musicologists and architects’ fame spread
around the world.

As the caliphate weakened at the beginning of the 9th century, power in the region

passed into the hands of the local feudal aristocracy of the Takhirids, Safarids and
Samanids. The end of the Arab yoke and the revival of local independence gave a new
impetus to the development of the previously frozen national culture. Having accepted and
mastered some cultural layers brought to the region through the Arabic language, and
using its own traditions, Central Asia became in the 9th-12th centuries one of the main
centers of science and culture of the entire planet [7].

Figure 1. Some principal cities and cities of the Central Asia’s Golden Age [8, P. 57].

The map which is described in Figure 1 belongs to the book “Lost Enlightenment”

by Stephen Star, who is a lecturer at the School of Advanced International Studies at Johns
Hopkins University and the President of the Institute for Central Asian and Caucasian
Studies. According to [9] the result of Stephen Starr’s efforts was a fundamental work on
an amazing temporal, geographical, psychological and social space – about Central Asia,
from the Arab conquest of 680–740 to the 15th century, to Tamerlane and his successors.
These were the Golden Ages, a new stage in the life of the ancient Central Asian civilization.


background image

Жамият ва инновациялар – Общество и инновации – Society and innovations

Special Issue – 8 (2021) / ISSN 2181-1415

106

At the celebrations of the 29th anniversary of Independence Day of the Republic of

Uzbekistan, the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan said: “In a time when the glorious
power of our people is in full swing, a new awakening is being laid in Uzbekistan – the
foundation for the Third Renaissance” [10]. Doubtless, the Third Renaissance will be a light
example of the progress of science and economics in our country, and surely it will be a
bright demonstration of all achievements accomplished with good intentions as serving
the people and to please people, the intellect of our people and our young generation, of
the power of talent [11].

Investments in science in recent years, the formation of the regulatory framework,

and most importantly, the conditions created for scientists and freedom of creativity have
defined our place in the Global Innovation Index. This can be considered as a step towards
attracting investments to science and innovation in the future [11]. It can be argued that
the scientific revolution has been the single greatest transformative event for humanity
since the harnessing of fire. Science has cured disease, unleashed the green revolution,
taken us into space, and shrunk the world through rapid transportation and instant
communication [12, P. 891]. Only science can provide solutions to many of the most urgent
needs of contemporary society. A conversation on how to reform science should begin now
[12, P. 895].

In the past years, science and scientific activities were considered to be significant

issues for the Republic of Uzbekistan. As evidence, we can refer to several legal documents
related to science and scientific activity that were adopted in recent years. President
Sh. Mirziyoyev signed the Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan about “On science and
scientific activity” LRU-576 on 29.10.2019 [13, lex.uz]. Scientific activity is an activity
aimed at the study of matter in order to determine the properties, characteristics and laws
of objects, events (processes) and the application of acquired knowledge in practice, and
includes fundamental and applied research. Fundamental research is theoretical and (or)
experimental activity aimed at gaining new knowledge about the basic laws of the
structure, formation and development of nature, society and man, studying the
relationship between them, as well as objects created as a result of a certain activity.
Applied research is an activity aimed at applying the results of mainly new knowledge and
fundamental research to achieve practical goals and solve specific problems [13, lex.uz].
Exactly one year later from the above decree, president Sh. Mirziyoyev signed PD–6097 on
29.10.2020 the Decree of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On approval of the concept of
development of science until 2030” [14, lex.uz]. This Concept is significant in terms of
human capital elements in the area of science. According to this Concept the following must
be implemented until 2030:

– Increase the share of total funding for science in GDP by 6 times by 2025 and

10 times by 2030;

– Increase the average age of researchers in scientific organizations to 45 by 2025 and

39 by 2030;

– Increase the share of highly qualified researchers (PhD and Doctors of Science)

in the total number of researchers under the age of 39 until 2025 by 2 times, and until
2030 by 3 times;

– From January 1, 2021 a system of training and regular training of heads of

scientific organizations at the Academy of Public Administration under the President of the
Republic of Uzbekistan has to be introduced;


background image

Жамият ва инновациялар – Общество и инновации – Society and innovations

Special Issue – 8 (2021) / ISSN 2181-1415

107

– Implementation of the “Academic Mobility” program from January 1, 2021;
– Allocation of grants from the Talented Youth Support Fund of the Youth Academy;

Giving these young people the right to freely use modern scientific equipment in scientific
organizations, higher educational institutions, as well as in scientific structures under
ministries, departments and organizations;

– and others.
According to the Decree of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On approval of the concept

of development of science until 2030” – PhD or DSc degrees which are obtained in higher
educational institutions overseas, which are in the list of the first 300 places at the
international rankings are directly recognized as DSc in the Republic of Uzbekistan. As well
as, The Decree of the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On measures to develop the
spheres of education and science in a new period of development of Uzbekistan” was
adopted in 2020 to improve the spheres of education, upbringing and science of the
country, to boost further increase in respect for teachers and pedagogical workers,
scientific and creative intelligentsia in society, development of the professional skills of
students, as well as expansion of the private sector’s participation in the educational
system.

In addition to this, the Cabinet of Ministers of the Republic of Uzbekistan adopted

several legislative documents to support the science such as the Resolution “On the
procedure of paying supplements to employees in scientific, pedagogical and labor
activities in all state organizations in the sphere of education and science” was adopted in
2019. This Resolution was adopted to create additional conditions for capacity building,
financial incentives for the practical application of knowledge and experience of highly
qualified personnel in science and education. Thereafter, the Resolution “On measures to
further improve the normative and legal basis for the development of research and
innovation activity” was adopted by the Cabinet of Ministers of the Republic of Uzbekistan
in 2020.

The year 2020 in Uzbekistan was announced as the “Year of Science, Enlightenment

and development of the Digital Economy in Uzbekistan”. The mechanism for allocating
targeted grant funds for fundamental and innovative research in science has also been
radically revised. It is worth to recall an incident, when president Sh. Mirziyoyev was
elected as a president, he first met with Uzbekistan’s leader scientists and this occasion
took place on 30.12.2016. This event was a new step in the development of science in
Uzbekistan.

We can count a bunch of results in the field of science and scientific activities in the

past years as well as at the current time in Uzbekistan. For example:

– The state order mechanism was introduced by the Ministry of Innovative

Development of the Republic of Uzbekistan in 2018 to radically reform the grant financing
system of fundamental, practical and innovative projects on the basis of the best
international practices;

– During 2017–2020th years several scientific, educational and innovation-oriented

organizations were organized. These organizations are: scientific and innovative
structures-32, technoparks-8, scientific centers-8, scientific-research institutes-18, and
new higher education institutions and their branches-29;


background image

Жамият ва инновациялар – Общество и инновации – Society and innovations

Special Issue – 8 (2021) / ISSN 2181-1415

108

– Mathematics, chemistry, biology and geology were established as priority areas of

education and sciencein 2020. As well as, 98 specialized schools and the University of
Geological Sciences were established;

– The mechanism for ensuring the professional development and training of

teachers-professors in higher education and research institutions abroad was established;

– 32 new academicians were elected at the Academy of Sciences. The system for

financing the activities of the Academy of Sciences from the state budget was established;

– A number of scientific-research institutes and centers have been restored;
– In the past few years, 300 billion sum funds were allocated to the institutes of the

Academy of Sciences;

– The Center of Islamic Civilization of Uzbekistan has been constructing since

2017 in Tashkent. The goal of Center of Islamic Civilization of Uzbekistan is to become one
of the world’s leading centers of science and enlightenment. The center is intended to be a
multifaceted center of science, history and activities in the various fields;

– “EL YURT UMIDI” foundation was established in 2018 and the purpose of the

establishment of this foundation is to develop sustain close cooperation with Uzbek
scientists, specialists and talented young people living and working abroad with great
scientific potential, training and advanced training of highly qualified specialists in leading
foreign educational institutions and in Uzbekistan’s higher educational institutions;

– During the year 2019–2020 about 1000 scientific events were conducted in

Uzbekistan, they include international events and republican events;

– “Scopus Award” ceremonies are held regularly by the Ministry of Higher and

Secondary Specialized education of the Republic of Uzbekistan and Elsevier Company. At
the awarding ceremony, academicians, researchers, higher educational institutions, and
scientific journals are awarded;

– The website of the Ministry of Higher and Secondary Specialized Education has

been launched www.moziy.edu.uz to cover the activities of our classical scientists in the
territory of our country;

– Over 100 masters have been being prepared by the Academy of Sciences annually;
– In previous years, scientists of the Academy of Sciences have created more than

100 new textbooks and manuals for Uzbekistan’s education system on basic educational
sciences;

– A number of joint scientific projects have been increased by professionals of the

Academy of Sciences and higher educational institutes for recent years;

– The Council of Young Scientists of the Academy of Sciences works actively. The

Council of Young Scientists conducts competitions on best projects, examines existing
problems, and implements measures to solve them;

– In the period of last years the number of women scientists increased, especially in

the areas of complex sciences in Uzbekistan. The Ministry of Innovative Development of
the Republic of Uzbekistan has taken the initiative to support women scientists. As a first
gesture in carrying this initiative, the Ministry of Innovative Development of the Republic
of Uzbekistan announced the competition of projects “Grants for women scientists” in
2020. The main purposes of this competition is attracting women to science in our
republic, supporting their ideas and overall development of women who are engaged in
science-education and scientific activities in various sectors and areas of the economy, as
well as creation of science-intensive products and innovative technologies.


background image

Жамият ва инновациялар – Общество и инновации – Society and innovations

Special Issue – 8 (2021) / ISSN 2181-1415

109

The president Sh. Mirziyoyev addressed the parliament of Uzbekistan – Oliy Majlis

at the end of 2020 and spoke on radical reforms of the six directions which must be
implemented in 2021. One of these directions is science and innovation to create the
foundation for the country’s development. According to this direction [15] next year, the
number of doctoral students at universities and research organizations will reach
4.5 thousand, which is thrice the figures in 2017. An additional 240 billion sums will be
allocated from the budget for these purposes. Based on the best international experience,
the scientific councils of the leading universities of the republic will be delegated the
authority to confer the academic titles of associate professor and professor, academic
degrees of Doctor of Philosophy and Doctor of Science. The Ahmad Fergani International
Scientific Olympiad in Physics will be organized. Additional measures will also be taken to
expand the scale and improve the quality of research in the field of physics, and create the
necessary conditions for young scientists.

Our future plan is to engage in science in the field of human resources management.

Through this paper, we intend to encounter the vast world of science and today, we already
started to construct the foundation of this life-long science building process. On this path,
we faced several problems as well as gathered some experience and today based on this
past experience we have several proposes. Our suggestions are related to higher
educational institutions and public administration organizations in Uzbekistan. They
include:

– to support of bachelor and master students in the participation in international

scientific conferences;

– to be active in publishing issues of bachelor and master students’ (who are active

in scientific research) scientific research papers in journals which are given on the list of
the Higher Attestation Commission of the Republic of Uzbekistan;

– intensification of work direct to activities in scientific activities and scientific

research between bachelors and masters;

– prevention of commercialization of republican and international conferences

which are conducted by higher educational institutions in Uzbekistan;

– to teach the scientific language of science at the 1st year of PhD level and establish

cooperation with foreign higher educational institutions with regard to PhD programs;

– to give information about science, scientific research, results of research,

researchers, scientists, academicians, and their scientific activities via mass media for all
participants in society;

– formation of a positive attitude of leaders/executives of organizations/entities in

the field of science and research.


CONCLUSION
This conclusion supports the fact that the progress of every country and society is

linked with the development of science. Attention to science and education is so vital that
it will determine the future of each country. Science is the light of the mind. It encourages
people to feel their existence, to understand the spiritual and material world, and to shape
their thinking. Science is the light of life. Science brings happiness to people’s lives and
removes their focus from ignorance. History gives strong evidence for this and no one can
refuse it. Based on the previous talks, we can say that there are all conditions for education
in our country for those who want to study. We have to always remember that we are a


background image

Жамият ва инновациялар – Общество и инновации – Society and innovations

Special Issue – 8 (2021) / ISSN 2181-1415

110

generation of great scholars who lived and lighted the world with science in the First and
Second Renaissances. The main sources of our religion The Qur’an and the Hadith
emphasize that science and scholars are of the highest status. We believe that science is
pivotal to laying a path for the formation of the foundation of the Third Renaissance in
Uzbekistan.


REFERENCES:
1.

Harper, D.: Online Etymology Dictionary, retrieved September 20, 2014.

2.

“Scientific Method: Relationships Among Scientific Paradigms”, Seed Magazine,

March 7, 2007, Archived from the original on November 1, 2016, Retrieved November 4,
2016.

3.

IX–XII-asrlarda yashab ijod qilgan O‘rta Osiyolik buyuk allomalar va ularning

jahon tsivilizatsiyasi rivojiga qo‘shgan hissalari, http://xorazmiy.uz/oz/pages/view/254.

4.

Muhammad Yusuf, M.S. (2011). Hadis va Hayot, 3-JUZ, Niyat, ixlos, ilm kitobi,

“Sharq” 2011. – B. 240.

5.

Academic dictionaries and Encyclopedias, Islam and science. (2017).

6.

Egyptian Muslim geologist Zaghloul El Naggar quoted in [http://discovermagazine.com/

2007/jul/science-andislam Science and Islam in Conflict] Discover magazine 06.21.2007.

7.

https://en-academic.com/dic.nsf/enwiki/4017174.

8.

Darling L.T. (2007). The Renaissance and the Middle East, (Guido Ruggiero / A

companion to the worlds of renaissance), Blackwell Publishing, 2007.

9.

Xodjaev A. (2018). Эпоха Ренессанса в духовной истории Узбекистана,

https://nuz.uz/kolumnisty/33953-epoha-renessansa-v-duhovnoy-istorii-uzbekistana.html.

10.

Starr S.F. (2013). Lost enlightenment: Central Asia’s golden age from the Arab

conquest to Tamerlane, Princeton University Press.

11.

Стахов Д. Мусульманский ренессанс, Взлет и падение средневековой

исламской культуры, https://gorky.media/reviews/musulmanskij-renessans/.

12.

Abdullaeva O. (2020). “Ўзбекистонда янги уйғониш – учинчи Ренессанс”,

https://uza.uz/uz/posts/-zbekistonda-yangi-uy-onish-uchinchi-renessans-03-09-2020

13.

Abdurahmonov I. (2020). Учинчи ренессанс – илм-фан тараққиёти,

https://mininnovation.uz/uz/news/2334.

14.

Casadevall A., Fang F.C. (2012). Reforming Science: Methodological and Cultural

Reforms, Infection and Immunity, March, 2012, Volume 80, Number 3. – PP. 891–896,
https://iai.asm.org/, DOI: 10.1128/IAI.06183-11.

15.

Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On science and scientific activity” LRU–576

on 29.10.2019, https://lex.uz/uz/docs/4825305

16.

Ўзбекистон Республикаси Президентининг 29.10.2020 йилдаги ПФ–6097-

сонли Фармони, “Илм-фанни 2030 йилгача ривожлантириш концепциясини
тасдиқлаш тўғрисида”, https://lex.uz/docs/5073447.

17.

President Shavkat Mirziyoyev’s Address to the Oliy Majlis, https://president.uz/

en/lists/view/4057.

Библиографические ссылки

Harper, D.: Online Etymology Dictionary, retrieved September 20, 2014.

“Scientific Method: Relationships Among Scientific Paradigms”, Seed Magazine, March 7, 2007, Archived from the original on November 1, 2016, Retrieved November 4, 2016.

IX-XII asrlarda yashab ijod qilgan O’rta Osiyolik buyuk allomalar va ularning jahon tsivilizatsiyasi rivojiga qo’shgan hissalari, http://xorazmiy.uz/oz/pages/view/254

Muhammad Yusuf, M. S. (2011). Hadis va Hayot, 3-JUZ, Niyat, ixlos, ilm kitobi, “Sharq” 2011, v.240.

Academic dictionaries and Encyclopedias, Islam and science. (2017)

Egyptian Muslim geologist Zaghloul ElNaggar quoted in [http://discovermagazine.com/2007/jul/science-andislam Science and Islam in Conflict] Discover magazine 06.21.2007,

Darling, L. T. (2007). The Renaissance and the Middle East, (Guido Ruggiero/A companion to the worlds of renaissance), Blackwell Publishing, 2007.

Xodjaev, A. (2018). Эпоха Ренессанса в духовной истории Узбекистана, https://nuz.uz/kolumnisty/33953-epoha-renessansa-v-duhovnoy-istorii-uzbekistana.html

Starr, S. F. (2013). Lost enlightenment: Central Asia’s golden age from the Arab conquest to Tamerlane, Princeton University Press.

Стахов, Д. Мусульманский ренессанс, Взлет и падение средневековой исламской культуры, https://gorky.media/reviews/musulmanskij-renessans/

Abdullaeva, O. (2020). «Ўзбекистонда янги уйғониш – учинчи Ренессанс», https://uza.uz/uz/posts/-zbekistonda-yangi-uy-onish-uchinchi-renessans-03-09-2020

Abdurahmonov, I. (2020). УЧИНЧИ РЕНЕССАНС – ИЛМ-ФАН ТАРАҚҚИЁТИ, https://mininnovation.uz/uz/news/2334

Casadevall, A., Fang, F. C. (2012). Reforming Science: Methodological and Cultural Reforms, Infection and Immunity, March, 2012, Volume 80, Number 3, p. 891– 896, https://iai.asm.org/, DOI: 10.1128/IAI.06183-11.

Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On science and scientific activity” LRU-576 on 29.10.2019, https://lex.uz/uz/docs/4825305

Ўзбекистон Республикаси Президентининг 29.10.2020 йилдаги ПФ-6097-сонли Фармони, “ИЛМ-ФАННИ 2030 ЙИЛГАЧА РИВОЖЛАНТИРИШ КОНЦЕПЦИЯСИНИ ТАСДИҚЛАШ ТЎҒРИСИДА”, https://lex.uz/docs/5073447

President Shavkat Mirziyoyev’s Address to the Oliy Majlis, https://president.uz/en/lists/view/4057