JME ISSN: 2751-1707
VOLUME04 ISSUE09
1
MORAL ORGANIZATIONS: ASPIRATIONS VERSUS PRACTICALITY
Ágnes Kovacs
University of West Hungary, Faculty of Economics, Sopron, Hungary
AB O U T ART I CL E
Key words:
Moral organizations, ethical practices,
organizational culture, ethical principles, practical
challenges, case studies, theoretical frameworks,
organizational ethics, implementation barriers,
ethical aspirations, real-world practices, ethical
ideals, feasibility, organizational behavior.
Received:
22.08.2024
Accepted
: 27.08.2024
Published
: 01.09.2024
Abstract:
In an era where ethical practices are
increasingly emphasized in the corporate and
organizational realms, the concept of a "moral
organization" has gained substantial attention.
This study explores the dichotomy between the
aspirational ideals of moral organizations and the
practical challenges they face in implementation.
By analyzing case studies and theoretical
frameworks, the research delves into the ethical
principles that define moral organizations and
assesses how these principles are integrated into
organizational culture and operations. The study
identifies key barriers to achieving moral
standards, such as conflicting interests, resource
constraints, and institutional inertia, while also
highlighting successful examples where ethical
aspirations have been effectively realized.
Through a comparative analysis of theoretical
aspirations and real-world practices, the paper
offers insights into the feasibility of creating truly
moral
organizations
and
provides
recommendations for bridging the gap between
ethical ideals and practical realities.
INTRODUCTION
The concept of moral organizations has increasingly captured the imagination of
scholars, practitioners, and the public alike, driven by a growing demand for ethical conduct in the
corporate world and beyond. A moral organization is often envisioned as one that upholds and
integrates high ethical standards into every facet of its operations, striving to balance profitability with
social responsibility and fairness. This aspiration reflects a broader societal shift towards valuing
transparency, accountability, and ethical behavior in institutions. However, the practical reality of
achieving such ideals is fraught with complexities. Despite the compelling vision of moral organizations
as paragons of virtue, many face significant hurdles in translating ethical principles into everyday
VOLUME04 ISSUE09
Pages: 1-5
JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT AND ECONOMICS
ISSN: 2751-1707
VOLUME04 ISSUE09
2
practices. Conflicting interests, resource limitations, and entrenched institutional norms can obstruct
efforts to implement and sustain ethical standards.
This disparity between idealistic aspirations and practical realities forms the crux of this study. By
examining various case studies and theoretical models, this research aims to unravel the challenges and
successes associated with creating and maintaining moral organizations. The goal is to provide a
nuanced understanding of whether these organizations can truly emdiv their ethical ideals or if they
remain an aspirational dream in a world dominated by competing priorities. Through this exploration,
the study seeks to offer insights into bridging the gap between moral aspirations and practical
implementation, thereby contributing to the ongoing discourse on ethical organizational practices.
METHOD
To explore the dichotomy between the aspirations and practicality of moral organizations, this study
employs a multi-method approach, combining qualitative and quantitative research techniques to
provide a comprehensive analysis. The primary research methods include case studies, surveys, and
interviews, complemented by a review of relevant literature.
The research begins with an in-depth examination of selected case studies featuring organizations that
have been recognized for their efforts to adhere to moral and ethical standards. These cases are chosen
based on their prominence in discussions about organizational ethics and their varied approaches to
implementing moral principles. Through detailed analysis of these cases, the study aims to identify
common strategies and practices that have been effective in bridging the gap between ethical
aspirations and practical realities. The case studies also highlight challenges faced by these
organizations and how they have navigated these issues.
To capture a broader perspective on the practical challenges of implementing moral standards, the
study employs surveys distributed to organizational leaders, employees, and stakeholders. The survey
design includes questions aimed at assessing perceptions of ethical practices, perceived barriers to
moral implementation, and the effectiveness of various strategies employed by organizations. The
responses provide quantitative data that reveal trends and correlations between organizational
characteristics and their success in integrating moral principles.
Complementing the surveys, semi-structured interviews are conducted with key informants, including
executives, ethics officers, and subject matter experts. These interviews offer qualitative insights into
the personal experiences and viewpoints of individuals who are directly involved in the ethical
decision-making process within organizations. The interviews explore topics such as the motivations
behind pursuing moral practices, the specific obstacles encountered, and the strategies used to
overcome these challenges. This qualitative data adds depth to the survey findings and provides a richer
understanding of the practicalities involved.
A thorough review of existing literature on organizational ethics, moral philosophy, and practical
implementations provides a theoretical framework for the study. This review includes academic
articles, books, and industry reports that offer insights into the theoretical underpinnings of moral
organizations and document previous research findings related to ethical practices and their
challenges.
The data collected from case studies, surveys, and interviews are analyzed using both qualitative and
quantitative methods. Case study findings are synthesized to identify patterns and lessons learned,
while survey data is subjected to statistical analysis to determine significant factors influencing the
success of moral organizations. Interview transcripts are coded and analyzed thematically to extract
JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT AND ECONOMICS
ISSN: 2751-1707
VOLUME04 ISSUE09
3
key themes and insights. By integrating these research methods, the study aims to provide a balanced
view of the aspirations versus the practical realities of moral organizations. The combined insights from
case studies, surveys, interviews, and literature review will contribute to a nuanced understanding of
the feasibility of creating truly moral organizations and offer recommendations for improving the
alignment between ethical ideals and organizational practices.
RESULTS
The investigation into "Moral Organizations: Aspirations versus Practicality" reveals a complex
landscape where the ideal of moral organizations often encounters significant practical challenges. The
case studies demonstrate that while many organizations strive to emdiv ethical principles, their
efforts are frequently hampered by a range of obstacles. Common barriers identified include conflicting
stakeholder interests, insufficient resources, and resistance to change within organizational cultures.
These challenges often result in a gap between the aspirational goals of moral practices and their
implementation on the ground.
Survey data corroborates these findings, with respondents highlighting that while the commitment to
ethical behavior is strong, translating these commitments into consistent, actionable practices remains
difficult. Many organizations report difficulties in maintaining ethical standards amidst competitive
pressures and financial constraints. Moreover, the survey reveals a general sense of skepticism about
the feasibility of achieving fully moral organizations, with respondents acknowledging that while
ethical ideals are aspirational, the practical execution often falls short.
Interviews with organizational leaders and ethics officers provide deeper insights into these challenges.
Interviewees frequently mention that achieving a balance between ethical ideals and practical business
needs requires ongoing effort and adaptation. They emphasize the importance of leadership
commitment, employee engagement, and the development of robust ethical frameworks to navigate
these challenges effectively. However, they also recognize that these efforts are often constrained by
broader systemic issues, such as market pressures and regulatory environments.
The literature review supports these findings, highlighting that while the theoretical foundations for
moral organizations are well-established, practical implementations are fraught with difficulties. The
review underscores the need for continuous reflection and adaptation to bridge the gap between ethical
aspirations and practical realities. Overall, the results indicate that while the aspiration to create moral
organizations is prevalent and supported by a theoretical framework, achieving these ideals in practice
remains challenging. The study suggests that bridging the gap between aspirations and practicality
requires a multifaceted approach, including stronger leadership, better resource allocation, and
ongoing evaluation of ethical practices. Recommendations include fostering a culture of ethics within
organizations, enhancing transparency, and developing frameworks to address and mitigate the
practical challenges encountered.
DISCUSSION
The exploration of "Moral Organizations: Aspirations versus Practicality" reveals a compelling
juxtaposition between the idealistic vision of ethical organizations and the often cumbersome realities
faced in their pursuit. While the concept of a moral organization is grounded in the noble goal of aligning
business practices with high ethical standards, the practical application of these ideals frequently
encounters significant obstacles. The case studies and survey results underscore that despite a strong
commitment to ethical principles, many organizations struggle with implementing these ideals
JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT AND ECONOMICS
ISSN: 2751-1707
VOLUME04 ISSUE09
4
consistently due to conflicting interests, resource constraints, and entrenched institutional norms. This
discrepancy between aspiration and practicality suggests that while the pursuit of moral standards is a
commendable and important endeavor, it is not without its inherent difficulties.
Interviews with organizational leaders reveal that while there is a sincere effort to integrate ethical
principles into organizational practices, the process is often complex and fraught with challenges. These
challenges include the need for continual alignment of ethical goals with business realities, managing
stakeholder expectations, and overcoming resistance to change within the organizational culture. The
results highlight that achieving a truly moral organization requires more than just theoretical
commitment; it necessitates a sustained and nuanced approach to ethical implementation. This includes
fostering an organizational culture that prioritizes ethics, developing robust ethical guidelines, and
providing ongoing training and support to employees.
The findings also reflect broader systemic issues, such as market pressures and regulatory
environments, which can undermine efforts to maintain high ethical standards. These external factors
often impose constraints that complicate the realization of moral aspirations, suggesting that a more
comprehensive approach is needed to address these external challenges. While the aspiration to create
moral organizations is widely endorsed and theoretically sound, the practical challenges of achieving
these ideals are substantial. The study suggests that bridging the gap between aspirations and
practicality involves not only a strong commitment to ethical values but also a proactive approach to
addressing the barriers that impede their implementation. Organizations must navigate a complex
interplay of internal and external factors to reconcile their ethical ideals with practical business
demands. Ultimately, the pursuit of moral organizations requires a continuous effort to adapt and
evolve, ensuring that ethical principles are not just aspirational but become integral to organizational
practice.
CONCLUSION
The study of "Moral Organizations: Aspirations versus Practicality" highlights the significant gap
between the ideal of moral organizations and the practical challenges encountered in their
implementation. While the aspiration to create organizations that adhere strictly to ethical principles is
both commendable and widely supported, achieving this ideal in practice proves to be complex and
fraught with difficulties. The research reveals that organizations often struggle with aligning their
ethical commitments with real-world constraints such as conflicting stakeholder interests, resource
limitations, and entrenched cultural norms.
The analysis of case studies, surveys, and interviews underscores that while many organizations
endeavor to integrate moral principles into their operations, the execution of these ideals is often
inconsistent. Challenges such as balancing ethical goals with business objectives, managing external
pressures, and overcoming internal resistance are prevalent. These findings suggest that the journey
towards becoming a truly moral organization requires more than just theoretical adherence to ethical
standards; it demands a continuous and adaptive approach to navigating practical barriers.
In light of these findings, the study recommends several strategies for organizations striving to bridge
the gap between aspirations and practicality. These include fostering a strong ethical culture,
developing clear and actionable ethical guidelines, and providing ongoing training and support for
employees. Additionally, addressing external factors such as market pressures and regulatory
constraints is crucial for maintaining ethical standards in a competitive environment.
JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT AND ECONOMICS
ISSN: 2751-1707
VOLUME04 ISSUE09
5
Overall, while the vision of moral organizations remains an important and aspirational goal, realizing
this vision in practice requires a nuanced and proactive approach. Organizations must be prepared to
engage in a sustained effort to align their ethical ideals with practical realities, ensuring that their
commitment to moral principles translates into effective and consistent practices. The pursuit of ethical
excellence is an ongoing process that demands resilience, adaptability, and a deep-seated commitment
to integrating ethics into every aspect of organizational life.
REFERENCES
1.
Bertók R. and Bécsi Zs.: Etika elméletek / Etika gyakorlatok. Ethosz Tudományos Egyesület, Pécs,
2007, 200. ISBN: 978-963-88149-2-0
2.
Etzioni, A.: The Spirit of Community. Touchstone Book. New York, London, Toronto, Sydney, Tokyo,
Singapore. ISBN: 978-963-06-1368-2
3.
Fekete L. and Zsolnai L.: Building Ethical Institutions for Business. Journal of Business
4.
Ethics, Special Issue. Kluwer Academic Publishers. 28. (1997)
5.
Gulyás Gy.: A közpolitika paradoxonai. PhDdisszertáció, Eötvös Loránd Tudományegyetem,
Politikatudományi Doktori Iskola, Budapest, 2002, 1-335.
6.
PSZÁF és a PBT közös kiadványa: Pénzügyi Békéltető Testület
7.
Toronyai G.: Kortárs etika. Nemzeti Tankönyvkiadó, Budapest, 2002, 52.
8.
Török A.: Racionalitás és etika a gazdasági döntésekben. Közgazdasági Szemle. 47: 918-930. (2000)
9.
Zsolnai L.: Ethics in the economy. Peter Lang, Academic Publishers, Oxford, 2004, 112. Available
form: http://www.uni-corvinus.hu
10.
Zsolnai L.: Interdisciplinary Yearbook of Business Ethics. Peter Lang, Academic Publishers, Bern,
2006, 82. Available form: http://www.uni- corvinus.hu
11.
http://www.mnb.hu/Penzugyi_kultura/kutatasok/penzu
gyi-kultúra-alapkutatas
Time
of
downloading: 21.04.2012.
12.
http://www.pszaf.hu/fogyasztoknak/tematikus-
_oldalak/szakmai_onszabalyozas
Time
of
downloading: 13. 03.2012.
13.
http://www.netbank.hu Time of downloading: 17.04.2012.
14.
http://www.piacesprofit.hu/klimablog/fenntarthato-
_jon_az_etikus_bank.html
Time
of
downloading: 19.04. 2012.
15.
http://atv.hu/cikk/20111024_uj_vilagbankot-
_javasol_a_vatikan
Time
of
downloading:
28.04.2012.
