YOSH OLIMLAR
ILMIY-AMALIY KONFERENSIYASI
in-academy.uz/index.php/yo
79
NOAH GORDON’S INTERPRETATIONS OF IBN SINA’S PHILOSOPHICAL
IDEAS: A LITERARY ANALYSIS OF
THE PHYSICIAN
Abdullayeva Nabiya Idrisovna
Scientific Supervisor: Professor, PhD
Alisher Khasanov Nabibullayevich
Master’s Student, Asia International University
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14630807
Annotation
This article explores the way Noah Gordon interprets and adapts Ibn Sina’s (Avicenna)
philosophical ideas in his novel
The Physician
. Gordon presents Ibn Sina not only as a medical
mentor to the protagonist Rob Cole but also as a moral guide and intellectual authority whose
influence shapes Rob’s personal and professional development. The article critically examines
key aspects of Ibn Sina’s philosophy, including the holistic approach to medicine, the
relationship between the div and soul, and the importance of ethics in medical practice.
Through Gordon’s literary portrayal, Ibn Sina’s contributions to both the medical and
philosophical fields are reinterpreted for a contemporary audience, highlighting the enduring
relevance of his ideas across cultures and time periods.
Key words:
Ibn Sina, The Physician, Intellectual Influence, Medical Ethics, Physician-
Princess, Spiritual Healing, Ethical Leadership, Philosophy of Medicine, Cultural Integration,
Body and Soul, Medical Mentorship, Intellectual Debate, Philosophical Approach to Medicine.
In the realm of historical fiction, few works engage with the rich intellectual history of
the Islamic Golden Age as vividly as Noah Gordon’s
The Physician
(1986). Through the
character of Ibn Sina (Avicenna), Gordon introduces readers to the complex philosophical
ideas of one of the most influential figures in both the Islamic and Western intellectual
traditions. Ibn Sina’s contributions to medicine, philosophy, and ethics remain foundational to
the study of science and philosophy across cultures. Gordon, while crafting a historical
narrative, subtly interprets and adapts Ibn Sina’s views on medicine, philosophy, and ethics,
integrating them into the narrative’s broader themes of personal growth, compassion, and
intellectual pursuit. This article critically examines Gordon's portrayal of Ibn Sina, focusing on
how Gordon adapts Ibn Sina’s key ideas such as the relationship between the div and soul,
the importance of empathy in medicine, and the holistic nature of healing.
In
The Physician
, Gordon captures the essence of Ibn Sina’s medical and philosophical
ideas through his portrayal of the titular character, Rob Cole, and the mentorship he receives
from Ibn Sina. At its core, Gordon’s narrative emphasizes Ibn Sina’s belief in the
interconnectedness of the mind, div, and spirit—a belief central to his medical practice and
philosophical system. For Ibn Sina, healing was not merely about treating symptoms but
about understanding the holistic nature of human existence. Gordon interprets this aspect of
Ibn Sina’s philosophy through Rob Cole’s evolution from an eager, inexperienced apprentice
to a compassionate and ethically grounded physician. Gordon's depiction of Ibn Sina’s
teachings on the importance of empathy in the medical profession is notably present when
the philosopher instructs Rob that "a physician must never treat his patients with contempt.
The patient’s trust is the most important part of healing" (Gordon, 1986, p. 318). This lesson,
deeply rooted in Ibn Sina’s ethics, underscores the central theme of empathy in
The Physician
.
YOSH OLIMLAR
ILMIY-AMALIY KONFERENSIYASI
in-academy.uz/index.php/yo
80
One of the key moments in
The Physician
that reflects Ibn Sina’s holistic approach to
medicine occurs in the debates between Ibn Sina and his fellow physician, Al-Razi. While Al-
Razi emphasizes the physiological causes of disease, Ibn Sina argues for the inclusion of
psychological and spiritual factors, claiming that "illness is not merely the affliction of the
div; it is the manifestation of an imbalance within the soul" (Gordon, 1986, p. 295). This
exchange encapsulates Ibn Sina’s belief that illness is a complex, multifaceted phenomenon
that cannot be understood through a reductionist framework. Gordon presents this
intellectual exchange not only to highlight Ibn Sina’s philosophical depth but also to show how
such ideas influence Rob’s growth as a physician who learns to treat the whole patient, not
just the disease.
Ibn Sina’s refusal to engage in unethical behavior, despite the potential political gains,
serves as an important lesson for Rob. It is through such ethical decisions that Rob matures
into a physician who, like his mentor, understands that healing goes beyond the physical act
and requires moral and philosophical considerations. This intellectual and ethical maturation
underpins much of Rob Cole’s journey, making Ibn Sina’s mentorship a transformative force in
his life.
Beyond his medical contributions, Ibn Sina’s philosophy had a lasting impact on both
Islamic and European thought. His works on logic, metaphysics, and epistemology bridged the
gap between Greek philosophy and Islamic theological thought. Gordon, through his portrayal
of Ibn Sina’s intellectual authority and mentorship, underscores the philosopher’s role in
shaping Rob Cole’s worldview. This relationship illustrates Ibn Sina’s broader influence—not
only on the medical community but also on the intellectual and philosophical climate of the
time. Gordon’s narrative allows readers to appreciate the universality of Ibn Sina’s ideas,
showing how these principles continue to resonate today.
Noah Gordon’s
The Physician
offers a rich literary interpretation of Ibn Sina’s
philosophical ideas, presenting them through the lens of historical fiction. By adapting Ibn
Sina’s contributions to medicine, ethics, and philosophy, Gordon provides readers with a
nuanced portrayal of one of history’s most influential figures. Ibn Sina’s belief in the
interconnectedness of div, mind, and soul, his commitment to ethical integrity, and his
philosophical depth are woven throughout the narrative, shaping Rob Cole’s growth as both a
physician and an individual. Gordon’s interpretation not only brings Ibn Sina’s ideas to life but
also underscores their enduring relevance in modern times, bridging historical gaps and
highlighting the universal appeal of Ibn Sina’s intellectual legacy.
References:
1.
Gordon, Noah.
The Physician
. New York: Bantam Books, 1986.
2.
Gutas, Dimitri.
Avicenna and the Aristotelian Tradition
. Brill, 1988.
3.
Lindberg, David C.
The Beginnings of Western Science
. University of Chicago Press, 1992.
4.
Nasr, Seyyed Hossein.
Islamic Science: An Illustrated Study
. World Wisdom, 2009.
5.
Walzer, Richard.
Avicenna’s Philosophy: A Study of His Philosophy of Logic
. Oxford
University Press, 1952.
6.
McVaugh, Michael R.
The Canon of Medicine in Medieval Europe
. Cambridge University
Press, 1997.
YOSH OLIMLAR
ILMIY-AMALIY KONFERENSIYASI
in-academy.uz/index.php/yo
81
7.
Van den Berg, Henri.
The Book of Healing and its Influence on Islamic Philosophy
. Brill,
2003.
