ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
122
DEVELOPMENT OF SERVICE IN ECOLOGICAL AND RELIGIOUS
TOURISM OBJECTS AS EXAMPLE, CHOR-CHINAR ECOLOGICAL-
RELIGIOUS COMPLEX, URGUT DISTRICT IN SAMARKAND REGION.
Gafforova Shahrizoda
“Silk road”International university of tourism and cultural heritage.
Faculity of tourism management.
Samarkand, Uzbekistan.
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.13841522
ABSTRACT
This master's thesis explores the impact of service quality on tourist
satisfaction and loyalty within the context of Chor-chinor religious and
ecological site. The study addresses the lack of existing services in religious and
environmental facilities, emphasizing the importance of improving quality to
attract and retain tourists. Through quantitative research and oral interviews,
the study highlights the significance of enhancing services such as transport,
dining, and auxiliary facilities to meet tourists' expectations. The research
reveals that the marketing efforts to attract tourists to the area are inadequate,
and basic services need improvement. Additionally, the e-service system needs
to be upgraded to meet modern standards. The findings suggest that service
quality elements have a significant influence on tourist satisfaction and loyalty,
with a positive relationship between visitor pleasure and loyalty. The study
concludes that tourists are dissatisfied with essential services, indicating the
need for enhancement in order to meet the evolving needs and expectations of
tourists. This research contributes to the development of ecological and
religious pilgrimage tourism, highlighting the economic benefits and
improvement in the standard of living for the local population. By identifying
shortcomings and offering suggestions for improvement, this study aims to
enhance the overall tourism experience at Chor-chinor shrine.
Keywords:
satisfaction, ecological tourism, religious tourism, Chor-chinor
shrine, service.
INTRODUCTION
The Central Asian region is known for its rich history and diverse natural
beauty, with Uzbekistan standing out for its ancient past and unique landscapes.
Despite its potential, there are still many undiscovered gems in this region that
have yet to be fully explored. In light of this, the government has taken steps to
promote the rapid development of tourism, especially focusing on religious
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
123
shrines located in ecologically significant areas. One of the key strategies for
promoting sustainable tourism in the region is through ecotourism, which aims
to protect the environment, preserve nature, and promote responsible travel
practices. Religious tourism also plays a significant role in attracting visitors,
with religious sites attracting not only followers of a specific faith but also those
interested in exploring the historical and cultural significance of these locations.
Ecotourism is defined as "responsible travel to natural areas that protects the
environment, observes its natural conditions, ensures the well-being of local
residents, and includes interpretation and education." This type of tourism not
only benefits the environment but also educates visitors and tourism workers
about environmental issues and cultural heritage. Religious tourism, on the
other hand, is a thriving segment of the tourism market, attracting visitors from
various backgrounds to explore the historical and cultural significance of
religious sites.
One such location that combines both ecotourism and religious tourism is the
Chor Chinor Sufi madrasa in Uzbekistan. With its environmentally pure
environment and a 12-century-old maple grove, it is a significant spiritual and
cultural site that attracts pilgrims and visitors alike. By improving the quality of
services provided at such sites and offering a range of additional amenities, it is
possible to enhance the overall tourism experience and contribute to the local
economy.
The main purpose of this research is to develop a predictive model of customer
satisfaction with the services offered at religious and ecological tourism sites
using machine learning capabilities. By identifying the most influential attributes
of such sites, it will be possible to enhance the overall visitor experience and
improve the quality of services provided. The specific objectives of the study
include analyzing the theoretical and practical aspects of tourism object service,
determining the most significant components of the Relational Model of Service
Quality in religious and ecological tourist destinations, and predicting customer
satisfaction with these sites.
By analyzing the quality of services provided at religious and ecological tourism
destinations, identifying key attributes that influence visitor satisfaction, and
developing predictive models, this research aims to contribute to the
improvement of tourism services in the region. By enhancing the visitor
experience and promoting sustainable tourism practices, it is possible to unlock
the full potential of religious and ecological tourism sites in Uzbekistan and
beyond.
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
124
LITERATURE REVIEW
Tourism is a dynamic economic sector that shapes contemporary civilization
development. Structural and conjunctural factors influence tourist growth,
presenting tourism as a means of fostering mutual understanding and cultural
exchange (Saidjalolov Saidafzal, 2020). The multifaceted nature of tourism is
driven by human desires for entertainment, information, education, and
personal growth within a post-industrial society (OA Bunakov, NA Zaitseva, AA
Larionova, 2018).
Development of services in religious and ecological areas
Various studies highlight the importance of sustainable practices in enhancing
tourism and preserving natural resources. Ecotourism, with a focus on
conservation and community engagement, seeks to strike a balance between
tourism and environmental protection (Liutikas, Darius, 2015). Religious
tourism, on the other hand, offers unique spiritual experiences aimed at cultural
and personal enrichment (K Shinde, Religions, 2021).
The Chor-Chinor shrine
The Chor-Chinor shrine, located in Urgut, Uzbekistan, is a sacred and historical
site that holds significant cultural and spiritual importance. The name “Chor-
Chinor” translates from Persian as “four plane trees,” which are a defining
feature of the shrine’s landscape. The sanctuary is situated approximately 3
kilometers from Urgut’s town and is surrounded by a stunning natural setting
that adds to its tranquility and mystique.
The grove at the Chor-Chinor shrine is adorned with over fifty ancient plane
trees, some of which are estimated to be over a thousand years old. These old
plane trees serve as a symbol of the region’s rich cultural heritage and spiritual
significance (Qulmatov Sh, Berdimurodov A, 2017). The massive, hollow centers
of these trees are believed to have been used as classrooms, adding to the
historical aura of the shrine.
Within the Chor-Chinor shrine complex, visitors can find tall adobe buildings,
winding streets, and vibrant ethnic groups reminiscent of Bukhara’s former
neighborhoods. The layout of the streets and homes, arranged on an incline and
spread out along both banks of the Urgutsaya mountain river, provides a unique
and picturesque ambiance to the sanctuary. The tranquil environment and
natural beauty of the grove make it a peaceful retreat for both pilgrims and
tourists seeking a quiet and spiritual experience.
An index attached to each tree in the grove indicates its estimated age, with
some trees dating back over eleven centuries. The trees and the surrounding
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
125
landscape create a sacred atmosphere that draws visitors seeking spiritual
solace and cultural enrichment. The presence of mosques, graves, and a holy
spring further adds to the shrine’s spiritual significance, making it a site of
pilgrimage and religious importance for many individuals (Soliyev A.S.,
Tashtayeva S.K., 2018).
In conclusion, the Chor-Chinor shrine stands as a testament to Uzbekistan’s rich
history and cultural heritage. Its ancient plane trees, historic buildings, and
tranquil surroundings make it a unique and spiritually significant destination for
pilgrims and visitors alike. The shrine’s peaceful ambiance and natural beauty
continue to attract those seeking a meaningful and serene experience in the
heart of Uzbekistan’s cultural landscape.
Summary
In conclusion, tourism plays a vital role in economic, cultural, and environmental
spheres, influencing global relationships and cultural exchanges. Sustainable
tourism practices, as evident in ecotourism and religious tourism, are crucial for
preserving natural and cultural heritage while promoting responsible travel
behavior (Rainisto, S.K., 2003). The development of services in religious and
ecological areas, exemplified by the case of Chor-Chinor shrine, offers
opportunities for enhancing visitor experiences and promoting cultural
understanding (Dmitry M. Astanin, 2019). By integrating these principles into
tourism practices, stakeholders can work collaboratively to ensure sustainable
tourism development and environmental conservation, shaping the future of the
tourism industry (Triantafillidou, B., and Koritos, A., 2010).
METHODOLOGY
Quantitative Research
Quantitative research is employed in this study to objectively describe the
perceptions of ecotourists regarding service quality at the Chor-Chinor shrine
for ecological and religious tourism. This form of research uses standardized
tools and statistical analysis to derive insights from predetermined categories
and expectations (Sakae, Y.; Kato, T., 2016). Data is collected through structured
questionnaires, surveys, and interviews to capture the frequency and extent of
certain facts and opinions within the target population. The approach allows for
statistical and mathematical techniques to be utilized in analyzing data to draw
meaningful conclusions about the service quality experiences of visitors to the
shrine (Goldkuhl, G., 2012).
Research Design
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
126
The research design focuses on quantitative methods, primarily experiments
and surveys to assess visitors’ perceptions of service quality at the Chor-Chinor
shrine. The study utilizes deductive reasoning and various analysis techniques
to provide descriptive data and establish statistical relationships through
modeling (Saunders et al., 2009). By applying quantitative research principles,
the study aims to quantitatively measure the level of service quality
development at the Chor-Chinor site and identify any variation in perceptions
among different regions.
Data Analysis
Data analysis in quantitative research involves the entry of raw data into
programs such as Microsoft Excel or IBM SPSS for evaluation of survey results.
While basic descriptive statistics are available in some tools, advanced statistical
tests can be conducted using programs like SPSS to analyze quantitative data
more comprehensively. Analysis methods will provide insights into the main
challenges faced by visitors at the Chor-Chinor shrine and identify shortcomings
in the services provided at the site (Goldkuhl, G., 2012).
Research Questions
The research aims to address the following questions to assess the quality of
service provision at the Chor-Chinor shrine:
1. What are the main inconveniences facing visitors to the Chor-Chinor shrine?
2. What are the shortcomings of the main and additional services provided at the
Chor-Chinor shrine?
3. What is the economic significance of the Chor-Chinor shrine in the region?
Interview Methodology
Interviews play a crucial role in gathering comprehensive insights and reporting
specific opinions of informants in research studies. The structured interview
process involves methodologies that emphasize research procedures leading to
quantitative analyses, such as questionnaires, interviews, and data analysis
(Gabble, G. G., 1994). The interview method will facilitate a deeper exploration
of visitors’ perceptions and experiences at the shrine, allowing for a detailed
examination of service quality and potential areas for improvement.
Data Collection Methods
Data collection methods will play a pivotal role in the success and cost-
effectiveness of the research project. Various data collection techniques will be
utilized, ranging from paper forms to portable electronic devices, to ensure the
collection of diverse perspectives from visitors at the Chor-Chinor shrine. The
recruitment of participants will be conducted transparently to ensure that
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
127
individuals who can provide valuable insights into the research questions are
included (Keith Crump, 2018).
Through a combination of quantitative research, interviews, and advanced data
analysis techniques, this study aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of
visitors’ perceptions and assess the service quality at the Chor-Chinor shrine,
offering valuable insights for further development and improvement in the
region.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
128
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
129
The analysis of the questionnaire data collected from tourists visiting the Chor-
chinar shrine offers valuable insights into the perceptions and experiences of
visitors. The historical significance of the shrine emerged as a key aspect, with
approximately 70% of respondents considering it extremely crucial. This
highlights the importance of the shrine in the eyes of visitors, showcasing its rich
cultural heritage and historical value. The ecological significance of the shrine
was also rated positively, with over 83% of participants considering it crucial or
extremely crucial. This indicates the environmental importance of the site and
its role in promoting sustainability and conservation efforts.
However, when it comes to the quality of services, certain areas showed room
for improvement. The transport services at the shrine were perceived as poor by
40% of visitors, suggesting issues with transportation infrastructure and
efficiency. Similarly, food services were rated as poor by 45.5% of tourists,
indicating dissatisfaction with the dining options available at the shrine. These
findings underline the need to enhance transportation and dining services to
meet visitor expectations and improve overall visitor satisfaction.
In terms of cuisine and dining experiences, 40% of participants expressed
disappointment, while 25.5% were indifferent. This suggests that improvements
in the quality and variety of food offerings could enhance the overall visitor
experience. Additionally, the price of goods and services was perceived as high
by 38.1% of respondents, indicating a potential need for adjustments in pricing
to align with visitor expectations and enhance affordability.
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
130
Despite these challenges, the data revealed a positive inclination towards re-
visiting the Chor-chinar shrine, with 70.9% of participants expressing a desire to
return. This indicates a strong interest in revisiting the shrine and exploring its
offerings further. Furthermore, an overwhelming 98.2% of respondents
mentioned that they would recommend the shrine to others, highlighting the
positive aspects of their experience and underscoring the potential for word-of-
mouth promotion and future visitations.
In conclusion, the survey results suggest that visitor satisfaction plays a crucial
role in influencing their intention to return to the shrine. Addressing key areas
such as transportation, food services, and pricing could enhance the overall
tourism experience and further attract visitors to the Chor-chinar shrine. By
focusing on improving service quality, the shrine has the opportunity to elevate
visitor satisfaction, foster repeat visits, and increase positive recommendations,
ultimately contributing to the site’s long-term success and sustainability in the
tourism industry.
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
131
The data analysis from the questionnaire responses provides valuable insight
into how visitors learned about the Chor-chinar shrine and areas for
improvement based on their experiences. It was found that social media and
word-of-mouth through friends and relatives are significant channels through
which visitors became aware of the shrine. This highlights the importance of
enhancing marketing efforts through social media and networks to increase
visitor awareness and attract more tourists to the site.
Recommendations for improvement were also provided by visitors, with a focus
on developing restaurant quality, improving household services such as
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
132
restroom facilities, enhancing internet connections, and addressing
informational gaps through information boards. Suggestions were also made to
enhance the quality of public transport, reduce prices for tourists, and upgrade
old tourist transportation to improve the overall visitor experience. Additionally,
recommendations were made to invest in destination marketing, improve
services, and provide non-cash payment options to cater to a wider range of
visitors.
The data indicates that visitors have identified various areas where
enhancements can be made to enhance the overall visitor experience at the
Chor-chinar shrine. The proposed improvements reflect the importance of
addressing service quality, pricing, transportation, and information
dissemination to meet visitor expectations and attract more tourists to the
shrine. By implementing these recommendations, the shrine has the potential to
become a more appealing destination, drawing a larger number of visitors and
contributing to the overall development of tourism in the Urgut region.
The analysis of visitor feedback underscores the significance of addressing
existing deficiencies and capitalizing on the opportunities offered by the Chor-
chinar shrine. By prioritizing the development of services, marketing efforts, and
infrastructure improvements, the shrine can enhance its appeal as a tourist
destination and provide visitors with a more enriching and satisfying
experience. As the region continues to evolve as a hub for ecological and
religious tourism, careful attention to visitor feedback and continual
improvement initiatives will be crucial in unlocking the shrine’s full potential as
a prominent tourism destination.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
The study conducted on visitors at the Chor-chinar shrine has provided valuable
insights into the tourism experience and areas for improvement. The potential of
the Chor-Chinor shrine as a tourist destination is on the rise, presenting
opportunities for economic development and job creation in the local
community. As the region seeks to capitalize on its natural and cultural heritage
through religious and ecotourism, enhancing services and infrastructure at the
Chor-Chinor shrine is crucial for attracting visitors and preserving the
environment.
Future research should focus on modifying tourist service quality, enhancing
visitor satisfaction, exploring return intentions, and expanding the scope of
tourism services at the Chor-chinar shrine. Consideration should also be given to
promoting modern farming techniques and incorporating the shrine into tour
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
133
packages to increase its visibility and attract a wider audience. By leveraging the
shrine’s unique natural beauty and historical significance, the region can
enhance its appeal as a tourism destination while promoting sustainable
tourism practices.
Recommendations:
To support the development and promotion of the Chor-chinar shrine, several
key recommendations are outlined:
1. Inclusion in Travel Agency Offerings: Add the Chor-chinar shrine to the list of
services offered by travel agencies to increase visitor awareness and attract
more tourists.
2. Marketing Strategies: Implement marketing campaigns to promote the shrine
and increase its visibility through various advertising channels.
3. Social Media Engagement: Extend the reach of the shrine by establishing a
strong presence on social media platforms to engage with a wide audience and
attract potential visitors.
By implementing these recommendations, the Chor-chinar shrine can enhance
its position as a sought-after tourist destination, contribute to economic growth
in the region, and offer visitors a memorable and enriching tourism experience.
Continued research, development, and strategic planning will be essential in
realizing the full potential of the Chor-Chinor shrine as a prominent cultural and
ecological tourism site.
References:
1.
Bihu, Reuben, Methodology of Questionnaire Surveys in Social Science and
Educational
Research
(
2021).
Available
at
SSRN:
https://ssrn.com/abstract=4435809, the International Journal of Quantitative
and Qualitative Research Methods, Vol.9, No.3, pp.40–60, 2021
2.
Dmitry M. Astanin*, Cherepovets State University, Cherepovets, Russian
Federation 2019.
3.
G. G. Gabble (1994). Combining survey and case study research methods:
an information systems example. 112-126 in European Journal of Information
Systems, 3(2).
4.
Taken from https://eprints.qut.edu.au/5853/1/5853.pdf on November
16, 2020.
5.
Goldkuhl, G. Pragmatism vs. Interpretivism in Qualitative Information
Systems Research. Eur. J. Inf. Syst. 2012, 21, 135–146. [Google Scholar]
[CrossRef]
6.
Liutikas, Darius (2015) “Religious Landscape and Ecological Ethics:
Pilgrimage to the Lithuanian Calvaries,” International Journal of Religious
ACADEMIC RESEARCH IN MODERN SCIENCE
International scientific-online conference
134
Tourism
and
Pilgrimage:
Vol.
3:
Iss.
1,
Article
4.
Doi:https://doi.org/10.21427/WHB7-CH60
7.
K Shinde – Religions, 2021 Sacred sites, rituals, and performances in the
ecosystem of religious tourism (google scholar)
8.
Monroe, K.V. Exploring Nature, Making the Nation: The Spatial Politics of
Ecotourism in Lebanon. PoLAR Political Leg. Anthropol. Rev. 2016, 39, 64–78.
[Google Scholar] [CrossRef] https://ecotourism.org/
9.
OA Bunakov, NA Zaitseva, AA Larionova… - Ekoloji …, 2018 –
search.ebscohost.com Development Perspectives of” Last Chance Tourism” as
One of the Directions of Ecological Tourism.
10.
Olsen, D. And Timothy, D. (2006), “Tourism and religious journeys”, in
TimothyRoutledge, New York, NY, pp. 11-21.
11.
Pradana, G.Y.K. Implications of commodified parwa shadow puppet
performance for tourism in ubud, bali. J. Bussiness Hosp. Tour. 2018, 4, 70.
[CrossRef]
12.
Rainisto, S.K. (2003), “Success factors of place marketing: a study of place
marketing practices in Northern Europe and the United States”, Doctoral
Dissertation, Helsinki University of Technology.
13.
Saidjalolov Saidafzal (2020) About The Content And Significance Of The
Resolution “Education And Religious Tolerance”- The Light of Islam: Iss. 1,
Article 4. Available at: https://uzjournals.edu.uz/iiau/vol2020/iss1/4
14.
1. Soliyev A.S., Tashtayeva S.K., Egamberdiyeva M.M. Geography of cities.
Study guide. – T. “Barkamol fayz media”, 2018.
15.
Sunartha, I.G.; Purnamaningsih, I.A.; Wafom, Y. The Meaning of Pura Agung
Surya Bhuvana (PASB) in the Religious Lives in Jayapura in the Global Era.
Humaniora 2021, 11, 59–69. [CrossRef]
16.
Sakae, Y.; Kato, T.; Sato, K.; Matsuoka, Y. Classification of design methods
from the viewpoint of design science. In Proceedings of the International Design
Conference—Design, Dubrovnik, Croatia, 16–19 May 2016; pp. 493–502. [Google
Scholar]
17.
TJ Akromovich – Ustozlar uchun, 2024 – pedagoglar.org
18.
Triantafillidou, B. And Koritos, A. (2010), “Pilgrimages: the ‘promised land’
for travel agents?”, Journal of Modern Hospitality Management International,
Vol. 22 No. 3, pp. 382-398.
