310
Sustainable Service Models on Quality Control and Management: Insights
from Nordic Countries
Madina Sayfullayeva
2
2
Bukhara state university, the department of tourism and hotel management, Bukhara,
Uzbekistan, sayfullayevam8@gmail.com, +998330290921, OCRID: 0000-0002-6624-1021
Abstract
Nordic countries such as Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Finland and Iceland are known for their
strong commitment to sustainability and environmental awareness and have implemented
various measures to ensure sustainable practices in the service sector. This article examines the
intersection of quality control and service management in the context of sustainable
development principles, using the example of Nordic countries and their experience. It explores
the critical role of sustainable development in optimizing service quality and operations while
supporting environmental, social and economic sustainability. By integrating sustainability
concepts into quality control and service management, businesses can improve customer
satisfaction, operational efficiency and long-term viability while reducing their environmental
impact and promoting social well-being. Through a comprehensive analysis, this paper
explains the potential of sustainable development to drive positive change and innovation in
the service sector, paving the way for a more ethical, sustainable and prosperous future.
Keywords
: sustainable development concept, service, Nordic countries, Ecolabelling, quality
management
Introduction:
The management of quality control and services is an essential aspect of all businesses and
industries, as it directly impacts customer satisfaction, operational efficiency, and overall
performance (Reed et al., 2000). and improving firm performance (Hendricks & Singhal, 1997;
Lemak & Reed, 1997; Samson & Terziovski, 1999). It is no surprise that the links among
market orientation, quality practices, and performance have attracted the attention of marketing
and operations management researchers (Samson & Terziovski, 1999; Ettlie & Johnson, 1994;
Flynn et al., 1994; Kohli & Jaworski, 1990; Narver & Slater, 1990). In recent years, there has
been a growing recognition of the importance of incorporating sustainable development
principles into these practices (Erol et al., 2009). Sustainable development seeks to meet the
needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own
needs (United Nations Brundtland Commission, 1987). Therefore, integrating sustainable
development concepts into quality control and service management is crucial for ensuring long-
term success while minimizing adverse impacts on the environment, society, and the economy.
Nordic countries, such as Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Finland, and Iceland are taking the lead
on such service models ensuring the quality of their service industry. This article will explore
how businesses can effectively utilize sustainable development principles to enhance the
quality and management of services.
311
Literature review:
Sustainable development concept in service industry:
Sustainable development in the service
industry refers to the pursuit of economic growth and prosperity while minimizing negative
impacts on the environment, preserving natural resources, and promoting social well-being. In
practical terms, this involves adopting sustainable practices and integrating environmental and
social considerations into business strategies and operations (MARIN & Lucian, 2013).
Environmental sustainability in the service industry entails reducing energy and water
consumption, minimizing waste generation, and mitigating pollution. For instance, hotels and
resorts can implement energy-efficient technologies, promote water conservation, and adopt
waste reduction and recycling programs. Healthcare facilities can focus on reducing the use of
hazardous materials and implementing eco-friendly practices for wast
e management (Bilińska
-
Reformat et al., 2019).
Social sustainability in the service industry involves promoting fair labor practices, supporting
local communities, and ensuring accessibility and inclusivity. This can be achieved through
initiatives such as employee welfare programs, community engagement projects, and providing
accessible services for individuals with disabilities.
Quality Management and Sustainability: A Synergistic Approach:
Quality management in
the service industry encompasses the systematic processes and practices that aim to ensure that
services consistently meet or exceed customer expectations. This involves a focus on factors
such as service reliability, responsiveness, assurance, empathy, and tangibles, all aimed at
delivering customer satisfaction and continuous improvement (MEHL & Elena, 2012).
Sustainability, on the other hand, encompasses the environmental, social, and economic
dimensions of business operations (URLAUB & Julie, 2011). It requires businesses to adopt
practices that promote environmental conservation, social responsibility, and economic
resilience, while also meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of
future generations to meet their own needs.
The Nordic countries shall promote the transition to a more sustainable form of development,
in which the region’s economies grow at the same time as damage to the environment is
reduced. The biological diversity and the ecosystem’s productivity shall be preserved in order
to ensure good living conditions for humans. It is important to find the balance between the
use, the value and the protection of natural resources. Emissions of hazardous substances
should cease as soon as possible or be successively reduced if they cannot be stopped
immediately with the purpose of minimising concentrations of these substances in the
environment. All sectors including service shall contribute to changing their production and
consumption patterns so that their goals are met (Nordic Council of Ministers, 2020).
In 2019, the Nordic Council of Ministers, the official div for intergovernmental cooperation
in the Nordic region, set a vision to make the Nordic region the most stable and integrated
region in the world by 2030. Long-term strategy for 2021-2024. A budget was adopted to enable
the implementation of the long-term goals set out in the 2020 action plan for the Nordic
region[16]. The 2020 action plan involves below issues:
Greater engagement of the business community through enhanced public-private
partnerships in the Nordic region's green transition efforts.
312
Invest in more initiatives that support the safe use of digital technologies such as 5G,
artificial intelligence and computerized solutions.
Strengthen the bioeconomy as a driving force for growth and green transition in the
Northern region.
Methods:
This article is mainly based on the case study method, in which it relies on the
experiences of service management models in the organization of the service sector based on
the criteria of sustainable development of the Nordic countries. The article is also based on the
results of a survey conducted by the Nordic consumer study 2022, based on qualitative and
quantitative methods, in order to research the services and consumers' attention to sustainable
services by ecolabelling service model in the Nordic countries. In addition, the article also used
the observation method on the documents of United Nations' related to sustainability.
Results:
According to sustainable development report 2023, on top of list, most Nordic
countries performed the highest indicator on SDG implementation in their countries. Below
the table provides an information about the top ten leaders on SDG performance
As can be seen in the table, most top leader countries are European countries, especially Nordic
countries. Nordic countries are taking the lead being on top lists of sustainable societies by
providing a balance between socio-economic, environmental aspects of their life. Sustainability
is on the top issue on every industry they have, provides quality ensuring people trust.
According to the Nordic consumer study 2022, consumers of all Nordic countries choose
services and goods based on sustainability. Below is a table covering these questions of the
survey. According to the given results, consumers of Iceland are mainly concerned about the
consequences of their actions on environment. Consumers from Finland and Iceland noted that
13
Countries are ranked by their overall score. The overall score measures the total progress towards achieving all
17 SDGs. The score can be interpreted as a percentage of SDG achievement. A score of 100 indicates that all
SDGs have been achieved.
313
Ecolabel makes their choice easier when choosing products or services. As can be seen from
this survey, the criteria of sustainability in managing the quality of services and products are
very important for the Nordic countries.
To summarize, such issues are the reason why sustainability issues are at the top in the quality
management of Nordic countries.
Integrated Approach: Sustainable Quality Management:
The integration of sustainability
principles into quality management in the service industry entails a holistic approach to
addressing the environmental and social impacts of service delivery, while simultaneously
ensuring the highest standards of service quality. This approach can be guided by the following
key principles (
LUŠŇÁKOVÁ
et al., 2012).
1. Environmental Responsibility:
- Adopting sustainable procurement practices to source environmentally friendly products
and services.
- Implementing energy-efficient technologies and renewable energy sources to reduce
environmental impact.
- Minimizing waste generation and implementing recycling and waste management
programs.
2. Social Responsibility:
- Ensuring fair labor practices, diversity, and inclusivity within the workforce.
- Engaging with local communities and supporting social development initiatives.
- Providing accessible and inclusive services for all customer segments, including people
with disabilities.
314
3. Economic Viability:
- Ensuring financial stability and resilience through efficient resource management and risk
mitigation strategies.
- Fostering innovation in service delivery to create economic value while minimizing
negative impacts.
Sustainable service models and quality assurance:
Nordic countries, such as Sweden,
Denmark, Norway, Finland, and Iceland, are known for their strong commitment to
sustainability and environmental protection. These countries have implemented various
measures to ensure sustainable practices in the service industry. Some key experiences and
measures from Nordic countries include (Nordic Council of Ministers, 2020):
1. Eco-certifications and standards:
Nordic countries have developed eco-labels and
certifications to promote sustainable practices in the service industry, such as the Nordic Swan
Ecolabel and the EU Ecolabel. These certifications provide guidelines for businesses to operate
sustainably and meet specific environmental standards.
2. Clean energy initiatives:
Nordic countries have invested heavily in renewable energy
sources, such as wind, solar, and hydroelectric power. Many service industry businesses in
these countries have adopted clean energy initiatives to reduce their carbon footprint and
promote sustainability.
3. Waste management and recycling:
Nordic countries have advanced waste management
systems, with a strong focus on recycling and waste reduction. Service industry businesses are
encouraged to minimize waste generation and implement effective recycling programs.
4. Sustainable transportation:
Nordic countries have prioritized sustainable transportation,
including public transit, cycling infrastructure, and electric vehicle adoption. The service
industry has embraced sustainable transport options for logistics and delivery services.
5. Consumer education and engagement:
Nordic countries have actively engaged consumers
in promoting sustainable practices. The service industry has focused on educating consumers
about sustainable choices, offering eco-friendly products and services, and promoting
responsible consumption.
Discussion:
Nordic countries have built a reputation for fostering a culture of sustainability and innovation,
and this ethos is reflected in their approach to service quality control and management. A key
aspect of sustainable service models in the region is the integration of robust quality
management systems that adhere to industry standards while emphasizing environmental and
social considerations. By implementing stringent quality control measures and environmental
certifications, Nordic service providers ensure that their operations meet the highest standards
of quality while minimizing their ecological footprint.
Furthermore, Nordic businesses have demonstrated a commitment to incorporating
sustainability principles throughout the entire service lifecycle. This includes the careful
selection of suppliers and partners who share their environmental and ethical values, as well as
315
the adoption of eco-friendly practices in service delivery and operations. Through these efforts,
Nordic service providers are able to maintain high-quality standards while contributing to the
preservation of natural resources and the well-being of their local and global communities.
In addition to environmental considerations, sustainable service models in Nordic countries
prioritize continuous improvement and innovation in quality management. This involves the
utilization of cutting-edge technologies and data-driven approaches to enhance service
delivery, minimize waste, and optimize resource utilization. By harnessing digital tools and
analytics, Nordic businesses are able to streamline their quality control processes, identify areas
for improvement, and drive efficiency gains, all while aligning with their sustainability
objectives.
Another hallmark of sustainable service models in the Nordic region is the strong focus on
stakeholder engagement and social responsibility. Nordic businesses actively involve their
employees, customers, and local communities in quality management and decision-making
processes, fostering a sense of shared responsibility and ownership. By prioritizing the well-
being of their workforce and engaging in socially responsible initiatives, such as philanthropy
and community development projects, Nordic service providers contribute to a thriving and
sustainable society while upholding high standards of service quality.
Moreover, the Nordic region serves as a rich source of best practices and lessons learned in
sustainable service models that can be applied globally. By sharing their experiences and
insights, Nordic businesses can inspire and influence service providers worldwide to adopt
sustainable approaches to quality control and management. This cross-border knowledge
exchange can lead to the development of a more sustainable, resilient, and interconnected
global service industry, benefiting both businesses and society at large.
Conclusion:
The Economic Benefits of Sustainable Development in the Service Industry:
Embracing sustainable development principles in the service industry can yield a variety of
economic benefits for businesses. Cost savings can be achieved through improved resource
efficiency, reduced operational expenses, and long-term resilience to environmental and social
risks. Furthermore, businesses that demonstrate a commitment to sustainability often attract
environmentally and socially conscious customers, leading to competitive advantage and
enhanced brand reputation.
Additionally, sustainable practices can drive innovation and create new market opportunities.
For example, the adoption of green technologies and eco-friendly services can lead to the
development of new products and services that cater to the growing demand for sustainable
solutions.
Benefits of Integrated Sustainable Quality Management:
The integration of sustainable principles into quality management practices offers a myriad of
benefits for businesses in the service industry. These include:
- Enhanced brand reputation and competitive advantage through differentiation based on
sustainability performance.
316
- Improved customer loyalty and satisfaction by meeting the increasing demand for
sustainable services.
- Operational efficiency and cost savings through resource optimization and waste reduction.
- Reduction of regulatory and compliance risks through proactive environmental and social
responsibility initiatives.
In conclusion, the Nordic countries exemplify how sustainable service models can elevate
quality control and management practices, setting a high standard for ethical, environmentally
conscious, and innovative service delivery. By integrating sustainability into their quality
management systems, engaging stakeholders, and fostering a culture of continuous
improvement, Nordic businesses have demonstrated that environmental responsibility and high
service quality can go hand in hand, setting a precedent for the global service industry. As
businesses worldwide increasingly prioritize sustainability, the insights and best practices from
the Nordic region can serve as a guiding light, shaping a more sustainable and responsible
future for the service sector.
References:
1.
Reed R., Lemak, D. J., & Mero, N. P. (2000). Total quality management and sustainable
competitive advantage. Journal of Quality Management, 5, 5–26.
2.
Hendricks, K. B., & Singhal, V. R. (1997). Does implementing an effective TQM
program actually improve operating performance? Empirical evidence from firms that
have won quality awards. Management Science, 43, 1258–1274.
3.
Lemak, D. J., & Reed, R. (1997). Commitment to total quality management: is there a
relationship with firm performance? Journal of Quality Management, 2, 67–86.
4.
Samson, D., & Terziovski, M. (1999). The relationship between total quality
management practices and operational performance. Journal of Operations
Management, 17, 393–409.
5.
Ettlie, J. E., & Johnson, M. D. (1994). Product development benchmarking versus
customer focus in applications of Quality Function Deployment. Marketing Letters, 5,
107–116.
6.
Flynn, B. B., Schroeder, R. G., & Sakakibara, S. (1994). A framework for quality
management research and an associated measurement instrument. Journal of
Operations Management, 11, 339–366.
7.
Kohli, A. K., & Jaworski, B. J. (1990). Market orientation: the construct, research
propositions, and managerial implications. Journal of Marketing, 54, 1–18.
8.
Narver, J. C., & Slater, S. F. (1990). The effect of a market orientation on business
profitability. Journal of Marketing, 54, 20–35.
9.
Erol, I.; Cakar, N.; Erel, D.; Sari, R. Sustainability in the Turkish retailing industry.
Sustain. Dev. 2009, 17, 49–67.
317
10.
United Nations. Available online:
https://www.un.org/en/academic-
impact/sustainability
(accessed on 6 February 2024).
11.
MARIN, Lucian E. A new world: sustainability and the service sector. [online], 2013.
12.
Bilińska
-Reformat, K.; Kucharska, B.; Twardzik, M.; Dolega, L. Sustainable
development concept and creation of innovative business models by retail chains. Int.
J. Retail. Distrib. Manag. 2019, 47, 2–18
13.
MEHL, Horst – HORSKÁ, Elena. Sustainable farming and new perspectives for the
farmer as energymanager for power-supply from biogas-reactor coupled with CHP. In:
Roczniki ekonomii rolnictwa i rozvoju obszarów wiejskich, s. 77-84. 2012.
14.
URLAUB, Julie. Can Service Industries Benefit from Sustainability? [online], 2011.
15.
Nordic Council of Ministers (2012). Sustainable Development – New Bearings for the
Nordic Countries, Report. 2012
16.
Nordic Council of Ministers (2020). The Nordic Region – towards being the most
sustainable and integrated region in the world . Action Plan for 2021 to 2024. URL:
https://norden.divaportal.org/smash/get/diva2:1508295/FULLTEXT01.pdf#page=1&z
oom=auto,-82,563
(last accessed: 06.07.2021)
17.
LUŠŇÁKOVÁ, Zuzana
– KLEINOVÁ, Katarína. The place of corporate social
responsibility and its activities in the retail firm management. In: Polityki europejskie,
Warsaw, pg. 53-61. 2012.
