https://ijmri.de/index.php/jmsi
volume 4, issue 4, 2025
1297
USING CRITICAL THINKING IN ENGLISH LANGUAGE TEACHING (ELT)
Kaxarova Madina Baxodirovna
EFL teacher at Bukhara State University, Fulbright Grantee
Abstract:
The innovation teaching methodology using critical thinking skills through cases,
activities, exercises; disadvantages and advantages of using critical thinking skills in language
learning lessons and enabling students to think and react independently in any situations,
practicality and skillful usage of language teaching is described in the article
Keywords:
critical thinking, ELT, integration, developing skills, methodology, problem solving,
water, eco, eco-friendly
Using critical thinking in English language teaching involves encouraging learners not just to
understand and produce language, but to analyze, evaluate, and apply it meaningfully. It shifts
teaching beyond grammar and vocabulary memorization to fostering deeper comprehension,
reasoning, and independent thought. Here’s a detailed look at how to integrate critical thinking
into ELT, along with strategies, benefits, and practical examples:
Why Use Critical Thinking in ELT?
Enhances Language Skills: Students engage with language in more meaningful contexts,
improving speaking, listening, reading, and writing skills.
Develops Lifelong Skills: Encourages analysis, problem-solving, and decision-making—useful
beyond the classroom.
Promotes Engagement: Learners become active participants, not passive receivers.
Builds Confidence: Thinking critically gives learners more control over their language use and
understanding.
Core Strategies to Foster Critical Thinking in ELT
1. Ask Open-Ended Questions
Instead of: "What is the capital of France?"
Ask: "Why do you think Paris has become such an influential city?"
Encourages evaluation and reasoning.
2. Use Authentic Materials
Articles, videos, podcasts, interviews, and news stories provoke thought.
Example: After reading an article, ask: "What are the writer’s assumptions? Do you agree?"
3. Debates and Discussions
https://ijmri.de/index.php/jmsi
volume 4, issue 4, 2025
1298
Topics like social media, environmental issues, or education encourage argumentation and
critical evaluation.
4. Problem-Solving Tasks
Real-world scenarios where students propose and defend solutions using English.
5. Compare and Contrast Activities
E.g., compare two characters from a novel, or two cultural traditions.
6. Encourage Reflection
After tasks, ask students: "What did you learn? What would you do differently?"
Example Activities.
Speaking: Debate
.
Topic: "Should homework be banned?"
Students prepare arguments for/against and justify their positions.
Reading: Critical Analysis. Read an editorial.
Ask: What is the author's main point? Are there biases?
Writing: Argumentative Essay
Topic: "Technology is making us less social."
Guide students to take a stance, provide evidence, and consider counterarguments.
Role Play. Scenario: Students act as city council members discussing how to reduce pollution.
Encourages use of persuasive language and critical evaluation of ideas.
Tips for Teachers
Model critical thinking: Show how to question and evaluate texts or arguments. Create a safe
environment: Encourage all ideas and avoid judgment. Use scaffolding: Start with guided
questions before asking students to generate their own. Integrate Bloom’s Taxonomy: Move
from remembering → understanding → applying → analyzing → evaluating → creating.
Final Thought. Incorporating critical thinking into ELT turns language learning into a
meaningful, active, and reflective process. It empowers students not only to use English, but to
think in it, helping them grow both linguistically and intellectually.
Here's a sample lesson plan that integrates critical thinking into an English language class,
designed for intermediate to upper-intermediate learners (B1–B2 CEFR level). You can adapt it
for younger or older learners.
Lesson Plan: Critical Thinking through Debate
Objective: Effective usage of new innovations in teaching and enable students to be able to act
independently and develop critical thinking
Students will: be able to think critically and use critical thinking. Practice speaking and listening
skills. Analyze arguments and develop opinions. Use persuasive language and critical thinking to
support their ideas.
Example: After reading an article, ask: "What are the writer’s assumptions? Do you agree?" 3.
https://ijmri.de/index.php/jmsi
volume 4, issue 4, 2025
1299
Debates and Discussions
Topics like social media, environmental issues, or education encourage argumentation and
critical evaluation. 4. Problem-Solving Tasks
Real- world scenarios where students propose and defend solutions using English
5. Compare and Contrast Activities. E.g., compare two characters from a novel, or two cultural
traditions. 6. Encourage Reflection. After tasks, ask students: "What did you learn? What would
you do differently?"
Here's a sample lesson plan that integrates critical thinking into an English language class,
designed for intermediate to upper-intermediate learners (B1–B2 CEFR level). You can adapt it
for younger or older learners.
Lesson Title: "Is Social Media More Harmful Than Helpful?"
Time: 60–75 minutes
Group Size: Pairs or small groups
Level: Intermediate – Upper Intermediate (B1–B2)
Materials Needed: Printed or digital article (short, balanced article on pros/cons of social media)
Whiteboard or digital board. Debate planner worksheet (optional – I can create one for you)
Lesson Procedure
1. Warm-Up (10 minutes)
Ask students: “What do you use social media for?”
“Can you think of any positive and negative effects of using it?”
List ideas on the board. Encourage students to explain why they think each point is good or bad.
2. Input: Reading & Critical Questions (15 minutes)
Give students a short article titled "Is Social Media Helping or Hurting Us?"
After reading, discuss in pairs or small groups:
What are the key points made? What is the author’s opinion, if any?
Do you think the article is biased? Critical Thinking Focus: Evaluating evidence, identifying bias,
questioning author intent.
3. Language Focus (10 minutes)
Introduce useful phrases for debating:
Agreeing: I see your point, but... / That’s true, however...
Disagreeing: I don’t think that’s always the case / I see it differently...
Giving examples: For instance... / A good example of this is...
Using critical thinking in English language teaching (ELT)involves encouraging learners not just
to understand and produce language, but to analyze, evaluate, and apply it meaningfully. It shifts
https://ijmri.de/index.php/jmsi
volume 4, issue 4, 2025
1300
teaching beyond grammar and vocabulary memorization to fostering deeper comprehension,
reasoning, and independent thought. Here’s a detailed look at how to integrate critical thinking
into ELT, along with strategies, benefits, and practical examples:
Why Use Critical Thinking in ELT?
Enhances Language Skills: Students engage with language in more meaningful contexts,
improving speaking, listening, reading, and writing skills.
Develops Lifelong Skills: Encourages analysis, problem-solving, and decision-making—useful
beyond the classroom.
Promotes Engagement: Learners become active participants, not passive receivers.
Builds Confidence: Thinking critically gives learners more control over their language use and
understanding.
Core Strategies to Foster Critical Thinking in ELT
1. Ask Open-Ended Questions
Instead of: "What is the capital of France?"
Ask: "Why do you think Paris has become such an influential city?"
Encourages evaluation and reasoning.
2.Use Authentic Materials
Articles, videos, podcasts, interviews, and news stories provoke thought.
Example: After reading an article, ask: "What are the writer’s assumptions? Do you agree?"
3. Debates and Discussions
Topics like social media, environmental issues, or education encourage argumentation and
critical evaluation.
4. Problem-Solving Tasks
Real-world scenarios where students propose and defend solutions using English.
5. Compare and Contrast Activities
E.g., compare two characters from a novel, or two cultural traditions.
6. Encourage Reflection
After tasks, ask students: "What did you learn? What would you do differently?"
Example Activities. Speaking: Debate
Topic: “Should homework be banned?" Students prepare arguments for/against and justify their
positions. Reading: Critical Analysis. Read an editorial.
Ask: What is the author's main point? Are there biases?
Writing: Argumentative Essay. Topic: "Technology is making us less social."
https://ijmri.de/index.php/jmsi
volume 4, issue 4, 2025
1301
Guide students to take a stance, provide evidence, and consider counterarguments.
Role Play. Scenario: Students act as city council members discussing how to reduce pollution.
Encourages use of persuasive language and critical evaluation of ideas
7. Debate Time (15–20 minutes)
Each side presents their arguments.
Encourage polite interruptions, questions, rebuttals.
Optional: A moderator (teacher or student) guides the discussion.
8. Reflection & Feedback (10 minutes)
Ask:Which arguments were most convincing? Why?
Did your opinion change?
What was difficult about debating in English?
Critical Thinking Focus: Self-assessment, reasoning, perspective-shifting.
Assessment (Informal) Observe students’ ability to: Express opinions clearly
Use critical thinking to build/rebut arguments. Participate actively
Extension Ideas Writing: Have students write an opinion essay on the topic.
Reading: Assign a follow-up article with a different perspective.
Listening: Use a TED Talk or podcast on social media and analyze its argument structure.
Critical thinking exercises in language teaching can significantly enrich learning, but they also
come with some challenges. Here's a breakdown of their advantages and disadvantages:
Advantages of Critical Thinking Exercises in Language Teaching
Enhances Communication Skills
. Encourages students to express opinions, justify arguments,
and engage in debates, which promotes more authentic language use.
Builds confidence
in using the target language in real-world discussions.
Promotes Deeper Understanding.
Moves students beyond rote memorization to analyzing,
evaluating, and synthesizing information in the language.
Helps internalize vocabulary
and grammar through meaningful use.
Develops Cognitive Skills
. Stimulates higher-order thinking (analysis, inference, evaluation),
which benefits both language learning and general intellectual growth.
Cultural Awareness and Perspective-Taking
. Many critical thinking activities involve analyzing
texts, media, or social issues, prompting students to explore cultural perspectives and question
assumptions.
Motivates Learners.
Real-world relevance and thought-provoking topics can increase student
engagement and intrinsic motivation.
https://ijmri.de/index.php/jmsi
volume 4, issue 4, 2025
1302
Fosters Autonomy and Collaboration.
Encourages learners to take ownership of their learning,
while also promoting group interaction and teamwork in discussions or problem-solving tasks.
Disadvantages of Critical Thinking Exercises in Language Teaching
Language Proficiency Barriers.
Low-level learners may struggle to express complex ideas,
leading to frustration or disengagement.
May require more scaffolding than traditional exercises.
Time-Consuming.
Requires more classroom time than drills or structured activities.
Preparing and facilitating these exercises
can be demanding for teachers.
Assessment Challenges.
Difficult to assess subjective or open-ended responses consistently. May
not align well with standardized testing formats focused on discrete skills.
Cultural Sensitivity Issues.
Some topics might touch on controversial or culturally sensitive areas
that can cause discomfort or conflict in diverse classrooms.
Teacher Preparation and Training.
Not all language teachers are trained in critical thinking
pedagogy, which can lead to superficial or ineffective implementation.
Classroom Management Concerns.
Encouraging open debate or discussion may lead to off-
topic tangents, dominance by outspoken students, or even conflict if not well-managed.
Bibliography
1. Kaharova M. B. Boosting education quality is not a myth anymore (from personal experience)
//Molodoy uchenyy. – 2016. – no. 14. - S. 544-546
2. Kaharova Madina Bakhodirovna. Group dynamics and the role play activities to raise
awareness on social issues in the ESL classes // Problemy pedagogiki. 2017. No. 5 (28).
3. Kakharova Madina Bahodirovna, "INTERNATIONALIZING UNIVERSITIES AND
STUDIES", IEJRD - International Multidisciplinary Journal, vol. 7, no. 1, p. 7, Jan. 2022.
4. Bakhodirovich, A. B. (2022). "Alchemist" Paolo Coelho. International Journal of
Development
and
Public
Policy,
2(4),
105–108.
Retrieved
from
http://openaccessjournals.eu/index.php/ijdpp/article/view/1236
5. Ahrorov Botir Bakhodirovich. (2022). Humanitarian values and social justice in Agatha
Christie's "Ten little niggers" mystery novel. Eurasian Scientific Herald, 5, 96–99. Retrieved
from https://www.geniusjournals.org/index.php/esh/article/view/615
6. Ahrorov Botir Bakhodirovich. Some teaching techniques recommended by TESOL
organization trainers and community to facilitate and conduct EFL lessons. "IMPROVING THE
QUALITY AND EFFECTIVENESS OF PRIMARY EDUCATION: STRATEGY,
INNOVATION AND BEST PRACTICES" INTERNATIONAL SCIENTIFIC CONFERENCE.
Bukhara State University, Uzbekistan. p. 462. 20th Sep.,2021. In cooperation with Ministry of
Higher Education and Ministry of Innovation.
7. Bakhodirovna, Kaharova Medina. "THE OLD MAN AND THE SEA (ERNEST
HEMINGWAY)." ONLINE SCIENTIFIC JOURNAL OF SUSTAINABILITY AND
LEADERSHIP RESEARCH (2022): 704-707.
https://ijmri.de/index.php/jmsi
volume 4, issue 4, 2025
1303
8. Kaharova Madina Bakhodirovna. (2023). MODERN REQUIREMENTS FOR
TRANSLATIONS OF SHAKESPEARE'S WORKS. Ethiopian International Journal of
Multidisciplinary
Research,
10(11),
281–283.
Retrieved
from
http://www.eijmr.org/index.php/eijmr/article/view/497
9. Kaharova Madina Bakhodirovna. (2023). HISTORY OF TRANSLATION OF WORKS OF
ALISHER NAVOI INTO FOREIGN LANGUAGES. Journal of Science-Innovative Research in
Uzbekistan,
1(8),
164–168.
Retrieved
from
https://universalpublishings.com/~niverta1/index.php/jsiru/article/view/2687
10. Kaharova, M. (2023). SPECIAL ASPECTS OF THE TRANSLATION OF
COLLOCATIONS. Innovative research in the modern world: theory and practice, 2(26), 20–22.
izvlecheno ot https://in-academy.uz/index.php/zdit/article/view/23124
11. Bahodirovna, K. M. (2022). "ALIEN" ALBERT CAMUS AND THE PHENOMENON OF
GETTING STRANGER. ONLINE SCIENTIFIC JOURNAL OF SUSTAINABILITY AND
LEADERSHIP RESEARCH, 709-714.
openaccessjournals.eu (http://openaccessjournals.eu/index.php/ijdpp/article/view/1236)
openaccessjournals.eu - openaccessjournals Resources and Information.
openaccessjournals.eu is your first and best source for all of the information you're looking for.
From general topics to more of what
