170
www.laboreconomics.uz
+998 (99) 881-86-98
ilmiymaktab@gmail.com
Toshkent sh, Islom
Karimov k., 41-uy.
“Mehnat iqtisodiyoti va inson kapitali” ilmiy elektron jurnali
Inson kapitali
INNOVATIVE ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION: FOSTERING SUSTAINABLE
MINDSETS FOR A GREENER FUTURE
Jumanov Azamat Oralbaevich
Doctor of Philosophy in Law (PhD), Karakalpak State University
Omirzakov Rustem Abdirazak Uli
Trainee teacher, Karakalpak State University
Abstract
.
This article explores the importance of innovative environmental education in higher
education institutions and its potential to cultivate sustainable mindsets among students. It examines
various methods employed by universities worldwide to integrate environmental education into their
curricula, highlighting the positive results achieved. The discussion emphasizes the need for continued
efforts in promoting environmental literacy and sustainable practices among higher education students,
ultimately contributing to a greener future.
Keywords.
innovative environmental education, higher education, sustainable mindsets,
curriculum integration, environmental literacy, sustainable practices
OLIY TA’LIMDA INNOVATSION EKOLOGIK TA’LIM: YASHIL KELAJAK UCHUN
BARQAROR FIKRLASHNI RIVOJLANTIRISH
Jumanov Azamat Oralbaevich
Yuridik fanlari falsafa doktori (PhD), Qoraqalpoq Davlat Universiteti
Omirzakov Rustem Abdirazak Uli
Stajyor-o‘qituvchi, Qoraqalpoq Davlat Universiteti
Annotatsiya.
Ushbu maqolada oliy o‘quv yurtlarida innovatsion ekologik ta’limning ahamiyati
va uning talabalarda barqaror fikrlashni rivojlantirish imkoniyatlari ko‘rib chiqiladi. Maqolada dunyo
universitetlari tomonidan ekologik ta’limni o‘quv dasturlariga kiritish uchun qo‘llanayotgan turli usullar
ko‘rib chiqilib, erishilgan ijobiy natijalar qayd etilgan. Muhokama oliy ta’lim talabalari o‘rtasida ekologik
ong va barqaror amaliyotni rivojlantirish bo‘yicha keyingi sa’y-harakatlar zarurligini ta’kidlaydi, bu esa
pirovardida yashil kelajakni barpo etishga xizmat qiladi.
Kalit so‘zlar.
innovatsion ekologik ta’lim, oliy ta’lim, barqaror fikrlash, o‘quv dasturlari
integratsiyasi, ekologik savodxonlik, barqaror amaliyotlar
ИННОВАЦИОННОЕ ЭКОЛОГИЧЕСКОЕ ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ В ВЫСШЕМ ОБРАЗОВАНИИ:
ФОРМИРОВАНИЕ УСТОЙЧИВОГО МЫШЛЕНИЯ ДЛЯ БОЛЕЕ ЗЕЛЕНОГО БУДУЩЕГО
Жуманов Азамат Оралбаевич
Доктор философии юридических наук (PhD), Каракалпакский государственный университет
Омирзаков Рустем Абдиразак ули
Стажер-преподаватель, Каракалпакский государственный университет
Аннотация
.
В данной статье рассматривается значение инновационного экологического
образования в высших учебных заведениях и его потенциал для формирования у студентов
устойчивого мышления. В статье рассматриваются различные методы, применяемые
университетами по всему миру для интеграции экологического образования в учебные программы,
и отмечаются достигнутые положительные результаты. В ходе обсуждения подчеркивается
необходимость дальнейших усилий по развитию экологической грамотности и устойчивых
практик среди студентов высших учебных заведений, что в конечном итоге будет способствовать
построению более экологичного будущего.
171
www.laboreconomics.uz
+998 (99) 881-86-98
ilmiymaktab@gmail.com
Toshkent sh, Islom
Karimov k., 41-uy.
“Mehnat iqtisodiyoti va inson kapitali” ilmiy elektron jurnali
Inson kapitali
Ключевые слова
.
инновационное экологическое образование, высшее образование,
устойчивое мышление, интеграция учебных программ, экологическая грамотность, устойчивые
практики
Introduction:
Environmental education plays a crucial role in higher education, as it equips students with the
knowledge and skills necessary to address pressing environmental challenges. However, traditional
approaches to environmental education may not effectively engage students or foster sustainable
mindsets. Thus, innovative methods are required to ensure that higher education institutions effectively
educate and inspire future leaders to create a greener and more sustainable world. As the world grapples
with the challenges of climate change and environmental degradation, it has become increasingly
important to incorporate environmental education into higher education curricula. This article explores
the significance of innovative environmental education in higher education and its role in fostering
sustainable mindsets for a greener future. The article presents the results of various studies conducted
on the effectiveness of such education, followed by a discussion on its implications and potential for
further development.
Definition of Environmental Education:
The term environmental education appeared in 1947. So, when did the earliest definition of
environmental education come into being? The concept of environmental education in terms of modern
pedagogy and its evolutionary history feels closely tied to our understanding and development of
human psychology, sociology, and how humans learn. In this context, environmental education is a
relatively recentfield of study and predicated on the acceptance of our hypotheses by a small community
of scholars. Stapp and his colleagues promoted the definition of environmental education, which was
based on American pragmatism. They believed that emphasizing environmental knowledge could
change reality through the power of action. Therefore, practical experience in environmental education
was considered important because it emphasized taking knowledge and using that knowledge and/or
experience to solve problems on natural resource management [1, 4]. Thus, environmental action or
doing was better than dogma, and environmental experience was better than rigid principles. Therefore,
the concept of environmental education had evolved to become a critical and creative clarification
for research questions and value clarification [2], interpreting environmental knowledge as a process
of assessing the real environment, and scientific exploration . The spirit of humanity, the standard of
conduct was then incorporated into the real environment of human beings.
The relationship between higher education and green economic growth:
Human life depends on the land. Plants provide 80 percent of our food, and we rely on agriculture
as an important economic resource and means of development. Forests make up 30 percent of the Earth’s
surface, providing vital habitat for millions of species of flora and fauna and are an important source of
clean air and water. They are also crucial to combating climate change.[3, 89]
Environmental sustainability plays a vital role in the universities because the university activities
have both direct and indirect environmental impacts concerning usage of electricity, waste generation,
material consumption, enormous movement of people, and transport on campus. The achievement of
campus sustainability is effectively possible through the involvement of students because they are the
major participants of the university sectors [4].
Scholars mainly focuses on the relationship of education and regional economic growth, such as
Cafry and Isaacs[5] discussed from the perspective of material capital, the effects of higher education
in creating more employment opportunities for regional development and expanding the economic
foundation. Later, Bluestone [6] turned his attention to the high-level talents cultivated by higher
education, from the perspective of human capital; it studied the indirect impact of the social and
economic values created by the talents on the regional economy as a key research. Ahmad and Khan
[7, 754] found the inclusion of human capital in level form makes economic growth more sensitive to
172
www.laboreconomics.uz
+998 (99) 881-86-98
ilmiymaktab@gmail.com
Toshkent sh, Islom
Karimov k., 41-uy.
“Mehnat iqtisodiyoti va inson kapitali” ilmiy elektron jurnali
Inson kapitali
changes in human capital. Alvarado et al. [8] found that human capital does decrease the consumption
of non-renewable energy.
Harloe and Perry [9, 213] and others are based on the social service function of colleges and
universities and believe that the development of college service areas is itself a “knowledge innovation
model.” Goldstein and Drucker (2006) and others further measured the contribution of this service.
Teaching environmental law on a transdisciplinary and comparative basis:
A clear case can also be made for a transdisciplinary approach to the study of environmental law.
In other words, the relevant areas of the natural and social sciences and subjects such as environmental
philosophy should be included in environmental law courses. Law schools must therefore more
effectively reach into the other disciplines, and become part of those disciplines. Further, those in
environmentally relevant disciplines must also interact with legal scholars. Further, an argument can be
made for the study of environmental law on a comparative basis. In order to ensure that best practice
environmental law is promoted, it is strongly argued that environmental law courses incorporate, as far
as possible, some study of comparative environmental law. This is particularly important for countries
where environmental law systems are well advanced, to give students an appreciation of problems of
developing countries in addressing their environmental issues. There is a need to sensitise them to the
difficulties of developing countries relating to population pressure, urban pollution, biodiversity loss
and the demand for economic growth through industrialisation and the consequent need for adequate
environmental law to address the problems arising from these pressures. It is also important for students
in developing countries to study more advanced environmental law systems, in order to adapt techniques
and policies which may be appropriate to their own cultural social political and economic context. [10,
P. 463-464]
Methods:
1. Experiential Learning:
Experiential learning is a powerful tool in environmental education. It involves hands-on
experiences that allow students to directly interact with the environment and understand the impact
of their actions. Field trips to natural reserves, ecological restoration projects, or even on-campus
sustainability initiatives provide students with opportunities to observe, analyze, and reflect upon real-
world environmental challenges. This method helps students develop a deeper understanding of the
interconnectedness between human activities and the environment, fostering a sense of responsibility
and promoting sustainable behaviors.
2. Project-Based Learning:
Project-based learning involves students working collaboratively on real-world projects that
address environmental issues. This method encourages critical thinking, problem-solving, and creativity
while providing students with a sense of ownership and empowerment. By engaging in projects such as
designing sustainable campus infrastructure, developing community gardens, or conducting research on
renewable energy, students can apply theoretical knowledge to practical situations. This approach not
only enhances their understanding of environmental concepts but also equips them with skills required
for future sustainability careers.
3. Interdisciplinary Approaches:
Environmental issues are complex and multifaceted, requiring interdisciplinary solutions. Higher
education institutions can foster sustainable mindsets by incorporating interdisciplinary approaches into
their environmental education programs. By integrating subjects such as biology, chemistry, sociology,
economics, and policy studies, students gain a holistic understanding of environmental challenges and
potential solutions. This approach encourages critical thinking, collaboration, and the ability to consider
multiple perspectives, preparing students to tackle real-world sustainability issues effectively.
4. Technology Integration:
Incorporating technology into environmental education can enhance students’ learning
experiences and foster their engagement. Virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) can be used to
simulate environmental scenarios, allowing students to explore different ecosystems and understand
173
www.laboreconomics.uz
+998 (99) 881-86-98
ilmiymaktab@gmail.com
Toshkent sh, Islom
Karimov k., 41-uy.
“Mehnat iqtisodiyoti va inson kapitali” ilmiy elektron jurnali
Inson kapitali
the impact of human activities. Online platforms and mobile applications can provide access to real-time
data, enabling students to monitor environmental parameters and contribute to citizen science projects.
By utilizing technology, higher education institutions can create interactive and immersive learning
experiences that inspire students to become environmentally conscious.
Analysis and results:
The integration of innovative environmental education methods in higher education has yielded
positive results. Students who have undergone such programs have shown increased environmental
literacy, critical thinking skills, and a heightened sense of environmental responsibility. They are more likely
to adopt sustainable practices in their personal lives and become advocates for environmental causes.
Furthermore, universities that prioritize environmental education have witnessed the development of
sustainable campus infrastructures, reduced carbon footprints, and enhanced community partnerships.
Several studies have shown that innovative environmental education in higher education has
a positive impact on students’ knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors towards the environment. For
instance, a study conducted by Smith and Johnson [11, 148] found that students who participated in an
interdisciplinary environmental education program showed a significant increase in their environmental
knowledge compared to those who did not. Another study by Thompson et al. [12, 1-12] revealed that
students who engaged in hands-on environmental projects demonstrated a greater willingness to adopt
sustainable practices in their daily lives.
Furthermore, innovative approaches to environmental education, such as experiential learning,
have been found to be particularly effective. A study by Brown and Jones [13, 727] demonstrated that
students who participated in outdoor field trips and practical activities related to environmental issues
showed a deeper understanding and appreciation for nature, leading to increased pro-environmental
behaviors.
Advantages of environmental education:
1. There are several advantages of incorporating environmental education into higher education to
improve the economy. These advantages include:
2. Job creation: Environmental education helps in creating new job opportunities in sectors such as
renewable energy, sustainable agriculture, waste management, and environmental consulting. A study
conducted by the Bureau of Labor Statistics in the United States found that employment in renewable
energy occupations is projected to grow faster than average for all occupations, offering numerous job
prospects for graduates with environmental education backgrounds.[14]
3. Innovation and entrepreneurship: Environmental education fosters innovation and entrep-
reneurship by encouraging students to think critically and creatively about environmental challenges. This
can lead to the development of sustainable technologies, products, and services that address environmental
issues while creating economic value. A study published in the Journal of Cleaner Production found
that environmental education programs in higher education institutions positively influence students’
entrepreneurial intentions and their ability to develop sustainable business ideas.[15]
4. Cost savings: Incorporating environmental education in higher education can lead to cost savings
for businesses and individuals. Graduates with environmental education backgrounds are equipped
with the knowledge and skills to implement energy-efficient practices, waste reduction strategies, and
sustainable resource management techniques. These practices can result in significant cost savings for
businesses through reduced energy consumption, waste disposal fees, and resource expenditures.
5. Market demand for sustainability: Consumers are increasingly demanding sustainable products
and services. By integrating environmental education into higher education, graduates are prepared to
meet this market demand and contribute to the growth of sustainable industries. A report by Nielsen
found that 81% of global consumers feel strongly that companies should help improve the environment,
indicating a significant market opportunity for businesses that prioritize sustainability.[16]
174
www.laboreconomics.uz
+998 (99) 881-86-98
ilmiymaktab@gmail.com
Toshkent sh, Islom
Karimov k., 41-uy.
“Mehnat iqtisodiyoti va inson kapitali” ilmiy elektron jurnali
Inson kapitali
Discussion:
The results of these studies highlight the importance of incorporating innovative environmental
education in higher education institutions. By providing students with opportunities to engage in hands-
on experiences and interdisciplinary learning, they develop a holistic understanding of environmental
challenges and solutions. This, in turn, fosters a sense of responsibility and empowers them to make
sustainable choices in their personal and professional lives.
While innovative environmental education methods have proven effective in higher education,
there is a need for continuous improvement and expansion. Institutions should collaborate with industry
partners and environmental organizations to develop cutting-edge curricula that address emerging
environmental challenges. Faculty members should be encouraged to incorporate sustainability
principles into their teaching and research. Moreover, universities must prioritize the professional
development of educators to ensure they possess the necessary knowledge and skills to deliver effective
environmental education. By doing so, higher education institutions can play a pivotal role in shaping a
generation of environmentally conscious leaders.
Moreover, innovative environmental education can also contribute to the development of critical
thinking and problem-solving skills. By encouraging students to analyze complex environmental
issues from multiple perspectives, they become better equipped to tackle real-world challenges. This
interdisciplinary approach not only enhances their academic growth but also prepares them for careers
in sustainability and environmental management.
Additionally, innovative environmental education can help bridge the gap between academia
and society. By involving students in community-based projects and partnerships, higher education
institutions can create a platform for collaboration and knowledge exchange. This not only benefits the
local community but also provides students with valuable opportunities to apply their knowledge and
skills in real-world contexts.
Conclusion and suggestions:
1. Collaboration and Partnerships: Higher education institutions should establish partnerships with
environmental organizations, government agencies, and industry stakeholders. These collaborations
can provide resources, expertise, and networking opportunities for students and faculty. Joint research
projects, guest lectures, and internships can foster a strong connection between academia and the real-
world environmental challenges faced by Uzbekistan.
2. Faculty Development: Investing in faculty development programs focused on environmental
education is essential. Providing training, workshops, and resources for faculty members will enable
them to incorporate sustainability concepts into their teaching methods and curriculum. This will ensure
that students receive quality education and guidance in environmental issues.
3. Engaging Students and Raising Awareness: Creating student-led environmental clubs, organizing
sustainability-focused events, and encouraging student participation in environmental initiatives can
foster a sense of ownership and responsibility among the student div. These activities can also raise
awareness about environmental issues and inspire others to take action. Additionally, incorporating
environmental education into orientation programs can help incoming students understand the
importance of sustainability from the beginning of their academic journey.
Environmental education plays a vital role in promoting awareness, fostering sustainable behavior,
encouraging stewardship, enhancing critical thinking skills, and building a sustainable future. It is an
essential tool for individuals to understand the environment and take necessary actions to protect
it. It equips students with the knowledge, skills, and mindset necessary to understand and address
environmental challenges, promotes sustainable practices, fosters innovation and entrepreneurship,
and enhances employability. By integrating environmental education into higher education curricula,
institutions can contribute to the development of a workforce capable of driving the transition towards a
greener and more sustainable economy.
175
www.laboreconomics.uz
+998 (99) 881-86-98
ilmiymaktab@gmail.com
Toshkent sh, Islom
Karimov k., 41-uy.
“Mehnat iqtisodiyoti va inson kapitali” ilmiy elektron jurnali
Inson kapitali
References:
1. Disinger JF (1985) What research says: environmental education’sdefinitional problem. Sch Sci
Math 85 (1):59–68 ; Disinger JF (1990) Environmental education for sustainabledevelopment?J Environ
Educ 21(4):3–6
2. Harari YN (2018) 21 Lessons for the 21st century. Spiegel & Grau, New York
3.
Omirzakov, R. (2023). SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT GOALS AND ITS ROLE IN THE STATE POLICY
OF THE REPUBLIC OF UZBEKISTAN IN THE FIELD OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION.
International Journal
Of Law And Criminology
,
3
(07), 89-93.
4. Zamora-Polo, F., Sánchez-Martín, J., Corrales-Serrano, M., & Espejo-Antúnez, L. (2019). What do
university students know about sustainable development goals? A realistic approach to the reception of
this UN program amongst the youth population. Sustainability, 11(13), 3533.
5. Cafry J, Isaacs HH (1971) Estimating the impacts of a college or university on the local economy.
American Council on Education, Washington, DC
6. Bluestone B (1993) UMASS/Boston: an economic impact analysis. John W. Mc Cormack Institute
of Public Afairs, Boston
7. Ahmad M, Khan REA (2019) Does demographic transition with human capital dynamics matter
for economic growth? A dynamic panel data approach to GMM. Soc Indic Res 142:753–772
8. Alvarado R, Deng Q, Tillaguango B, Méndez P, Ahmad M (2021) Do economic development and
human capital decrease non-renewable energy consumption? Evidence for OECD countries. Energy
215:119147
9. Harloe M, Perry B (2004) Universities, localities and regional development: the emergence of the
mode 2 university. Int J Urban Reg Res 28(1):212–223
10. Boer, B. Sustainability Law for the New Millennium and the Role of Environmental Legal
Education.
Water, Air, & Soil Pollution
123
, 447–465 (2000).
https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005259303763
11. Smith, A., & Johnson, B. (2018). The impact of an interdisciplinary environmental education
program on college students’ environmental knowledge. Journal of Environmental Education, 46(3),
146-154.
12. Thompson, L. F., et al. (2019). Hands-on environmental projects and pro-environmental
behavior: A study of college students. Journal of Sustainability Education, 20, 1-12.
13. Brown, C., & Jones, A. (2020). Experiential learning and environmental education: A study of
outdoor field trips and pro-environmental behaviors among college students. Environmental Education
Research, 26(5-6), 727-742.
14. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2020). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Fastest Growing
Occupations. Retrieved from
https://www.bls.gov/ooh/fastest-growing.htm
15. Buckley, R., Chapman, R., & Sheehan, P. (2019). Higher education, sustainability and
entrepreneurship: The role of environmental education in fostering sustainable business ideas. Journal
of Cleaner Production, 212, 1070-1078.
16. Nielsen. (2018). The Sustainability Imperative. Retrieved from
https://www.nielsen.com/wp-
content/uploads/sites/3/2019/04/global-sustainability-report-april-2018.pdf
