151
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
PEDAGOGIKA FANLARI
Makhmudov Kudratbek
Chirchik State Pedagogical University
UDК: 378.145.3
CULTURALLY RESPONSIVE TEACHING AND LEARNING
Keywords:
culture,
intercultural
communication,
culturally responsive
teaching, culturally
responsive learning,
teaching English.
Annotation.
The article is about culturally responsive teaching and
learning. In this research culturally responsive teaching and learning is
defined, and culturally responsive strategies to language teaching is
applied. As we know, diversity in the classroom is becoming increasingly
common, and it is important for teachers to recognize and value the
different cultures and backgrounds of their students. Culturally responsive
teaching and learning is an approach that recognizes and responds to the
diverse needs of students in the classroom.
MADANIYATLARARO TA’LIMDA O‘QITISH VA O‘RGANISH
Qudratbek Maxmudov
Chirchiq davlat pedagogika universiteti
Kalit so'zlar:
madaniyat,
madaniyatlararo
muloqot,
madaniyatlararo
ta’limda o'qitish,
madaniyatlararo
ta’limda o‘rganish,
ingliz tilini o‘qitish.
Annotatsiya.
Maqola til o‘qitishda madaniy jihatlarga muvofiq dars o‘tish
va o‘rganish haqida bo‘lib, uning tadqiqotida madaniyatlararo ta’lim
muhitida o‘qitish va o‘rganish ta’rifi ishlab chiqiladi va til o‘qitishda
madaniy jihatdan hisobga olinishi lozim bo‘lgan strategiyalar keltiriladi.
Barchamizga ma’lumki, bugungi sinflardagi madaniy xilma-xillik tobora
kengayib bormoqda va o‘qituvchilar o‘quvchilarining turli madaniyatlari va
kelib chiqishini dars jarayonida hisobga olishlari va qadrlashlari muhim
ahamiyatga ega. Madaniy jihatlarni inobatga olib o‘qitish va o‘rganish - bu
sinfdagi o‘quvchilarning turli ehtiyojlarini o‘z ichiga oladigan va ularga
javob beradigan yondashuv hisoblanadi.
ПРЕПОДАВАНИЯ И ОБУЧЕНИЯ В МЕЖКУЛЬТУРНОМ
ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ
Махмудов Кудратбек
Чирчикский государственный педагогический университет
Ключевые слова:
культура,
межкультурная
коммуникация,
культурно-
ориентированное
обучение,
культурно-
Аннотация.
Статья посвящена преподаванию и обучению с учетом
культурных особенностей. В этом исследовании определяется
преподавание и обучение, учитывающее культурные особенности,
которые в свою очередь, учитывая необходимые данные, развивают
стратегии преподавания языка. Как известно, разнообразие в классе
становится все более распространенным явлением, и учителям важно
признавать и ценить различные культуры и происхождение своих
учеников. Преподавание и обучение с учетом культурных
152
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
ориентированное
обучение,
преподавание
английского языка.
особенностей — это подход, который признает и отвечает
разнообразным потребностям учащихся в классе.
Introduction
Culturally responsive teaching and learning is an approach to education that
recognizes the importance of culture and diversity in the learning process. This
approach emphasizes the need for teachers to understand and acknowledge the cultural
backgrounds and experiences of their students, and to use this understanding to inform
their teaching practices.
At the core of culturally responsive teaching and learning is the recognition that
students come from diverse cultural backgrounds, and that these backgrounds can
impact their learning experiences. By acknowledging and valuing students' cultural
identities and experiences, teachers can create an inclusive and supportive learning
environment that fosters engagement, motivation, and academic success.
Culturally responsive teaching and learning involves several key principles,
including:
1.
Understanding students' cultural backgrounds and experiences:
Teachers
should take the time to learn about their students' cultures and backgrounds, including
their language, traditions, values, and beliefs. This understanding can help teachers
better connect with their students, and create a learning environment that is respectful
and supportive of diverse perspectives.
2.
Incorporating culturally relevant materials and activities:
Teachers
should incorporate materials and activities that reflect the cultural backgrounds and
experiences of their students. This can include literature, music, art, and other materials
that represent the diversity of the classroom.
3.
Creating a supportive learning environment:
Teachers should create a
learning environment that is welcoming and supportive of all students, regardless of
their cultural background. This can involve building strong relationships with students,
providing opportunities for collaboration and discussion, and recognizing and valuing
the diverse perspectives and experiences of all students.
4.
Using culturally responsive teaching practices:
Teachers should use
teaching practices that are responsive to the cultural backgrounds and experiences of
their students. This can involve using instructional strategies that are relevant and
engaging for all students, and that take into account the different learning styles and
needs of individual students.
153
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
By applying these principles in their teaching practices, teachers can create a
culturally responsive learning environment that promotes academic success and fosters
a sense of community and belonging for all students.
Culturally responsive teaching and learning has been shown to have numerous
benefits for students, including improved academic achievement, increased
engagement and motivation, and greater social-emotional well-being. Additionally,
this approach can help to reduce achievement gaps and promote equity and social
justice in the classroom.
In language teaching, culturally responsive strategies can be used to help
students develop language skills that are relevant and applicable to their cultural
contexts. By incorporating culturally relevant materials and activities, and using
teaching practices that are responsive to students' cultural backgrounds and
experiences, language teachers can create a learning environment that is engaging,
motivating, and supportive of all students.
Overall, culturally responsive teaching and learning is an essential approach to
education that recognizes the importance of culture and diversity in the learning
process. By valuing and incorporating students' cultural backgrounds and experiences
into their teaching practices, teachers can create a supportive and inclusive learning
environment that promotes academic success and fosters a sense of community and
belonging for all students.
Cultural responsiveness in language teaching is critical to ensuring that all
students, regardless of their cultural background, feel valued and respected in the
classroom. When teachers are culturally responsive, they recognize the importance of
students' cultural identities, experiences, and knowledge, and use this understanding to
create a positive and inclusive learning environment.
In this research, we will explore some examples of culturally responsive strategies for
language teaching, and discuss their potential benefits for both teachers and students.
Here are some examples of culturally responsive strategies for language teaching:
1.
Use of Culturally Relevant Materials:
Incorporating materials that reflect
the cultural backgrounds and experiences of students can help make the language
learning experience more engaging and relevant. For example, using literature, music,
and film from students' cultures or featuring characters and situations that are familiar
to them.
2.
Incorporate Students' Languages:
Allowing students to use their home
languages in the classroom can create a more inclusive environment and also provide
opportunities for language learning and practice.
3.
Culturally Sensitive Teaching Methods:
Using teaching methods that are
sensitive to cultural differences can help students feel more comfortable and engaged
154
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
in the learning process. For example, using group work and collaborative learning, as
opposed to individual work and competition, which may be more common in some
cultures.
4.
Encourage Cultural Exchange:
Providing opportunities for students to
interact with people from different cultures, either through in-person interactions or
online exchanges, can help promote cross-cultural understanding and provide valuable
language learning opportunities.
5.
Promote Student Autonomy:
Allowing students to have a voice and take
ownership of their learning can help build their confidence and empower them to take
risks and try new things. This can be achieved through project-based learning, student-
led discussions, and other student-centered approaches.
6.
Address Stereotypes and Biases:
Being aware of and addressing stereotypes
and biases that may exist in the classroom can help create a more inclusive and
respectful environment. This can involve challenging stereotypes through discussions
and activities, as well as being aware of the cultural norms and values that may be
present in the classroom and how they may impact student learning.
One of the main reasons why cultural responsiveness is so important in language
teaching is because it can have a significant impact on students' academic achievement.
Studies have shown that students who feel that their cultural backgrounds are
acknowledged and respected in the classroom are more likely to be motivated to learn,
have higher levels of academic engagement, and perform better academically. In
contrast, students who feel that their cultural backgrounds are not valued or
acknowledged are more likely to feel disconnected from school, disengaged from
learning, and may even develop negative attitudes towards their own cultural identities.
Another reason why cultural responsiveness is important in language teaching is
because it can promote social justice and equity in education. Students from diverse
cultural backgrounds are often marginalized in education, and may not have access to
the same opportunities and resources as their peers. When teachers are culturally
responsive, they can help to reduce these inequities by creating a classroom
environment that values diversity and promotes inclusivity.
Culturally responsive teaching is also important in preparing students for the
globalized world in which we live. In today's interconnected world, it is becoming
increasingly important for individuals to be able to communicate and work effectively
with people from diverse cultural backgrounds. By providing students with
opportunities to learn about and appreciate other cultures, and by fostering intercultural
communication skills, teachers can help to prepare their students for success in the
global marketplace.
155
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
Furthermore, culturally responsive teaching can help to promote a positive
school climate and build relationships between teachers, students, and families. When
teachers demonstrate cultural competence and show respect for students' cultural
backgrounds, they can build trust and rapport with their students and their families.
This can help to create a positive and supportive learning environment where students
feel safe and valued.
We can conclude that cultural responsiveness is essential for promoting
academic achievement, social justice, intercultural competence, and positive school
climate in language teaching. Teachers who are culturally responsive can help to create
an inclusive and supportive learning environment where all students can thrive.
Now let’s see some possible key characteristics of culturally responsive teaching
and learning that could be discussed in the class are:
1.
Valuing and integrating diverse cultures:
Culturally responsive teachers
recognize the importance of diverse cultures and integrate them into their teaching
practices. They incorporate students' cultural backgrounds into their lessons, and use
culturally relevant materials and resources to enhance learning.
2.
Building relationships and creating a welcoming environment:
Culturally
responsive teachers establish positive relationships with their students and create a
welcoming and inclusive environment. They show interest in their students' lives,
cultures, and experiences, and promote a sense of belonging and respect.
3.
Fostering high expectations and academic achievement:
Culturally
responsive teachers set high expectations for all students and provide challenging
learning opportunities. They help students to develop academic and social skills that
promote success in and beyond the classroom.
4.
Adapting instructional strategies:
Culturally responsive teachers adapt their
instructional strategies to meet the needs and learning styles of diverse students. They
use a variety of instructional methods and techniques, and allow for flexibility and
creativity in their teaching.
5.
Incorporating multicultural perspectives:
Culturally responsive teachers
incorporate multicultural perspectives into their curriculum and instruction. They help
students to see the relevance of their learning to their own lives and experiences, and
to the world around them.
6.
Engaging families and communities:
Culturally responsive teachers engage
families and communities in the learning process. They work collaboratively with
families and community members to support student achievement and to promote
cultural understanding.
7.
Reflecting on and adjusting practices:
Culturally responsive teachers reflect
on their own cultural biases and assumptions, and adjust their practices accordingly.
156
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
They seek out professional development opportunities and stay current on best
practices for culturally responsive teaching and learning.
Generalizing these characteristics a teacher can ask the students the following
questions in the class to facilitate the whole-class discussion:
•
What does culturally responsive teaching and learning mean to you?
•
Why is culturally responsive teaching and learning important in today's
diverse classrooms?
•
What are some challenges that teachers may face in implementing culturally
responsive teaching and learning practices?
•
What are some benefits that students may experience as a result of culturally
responsive teaching and learning?
•
How can teachers ensure that they are being culturally responsive in their
teaching practices?
•
What are some examples of culturally responsive teaching and learning
practices that you have seen or experienced in your own education?
7.
Culturally responsive teaching is an approach to education that recognizes and
values the diverse cultural backgrounds and experiences of students, and seeks to adapt
teaching practices to meet their needs. When applied to language teaching, culturally
responsive strategies can help create a more engaging and effective learning
experience, by incorporating students' cultural backgrounds and promoting inclusivity
in the classroom.
To sum up, culturally responsive strategies for language teaching involve being
aware of and responsive to the cultural backgrounds and experiences of students, and
adapting teaching practices to promote inclusivity and engagement.
Results
Culturally responsive teaching is an essential component of creating an inclusive
and equitable classroom environment. It involves recognizing and valuing the cultural
diversity of students and adapting teaching practices to meet their unique needs. In this
context, educators can use various activities and exercises to explore personal cultural
values, adapt teaching materials, and apply frameworks for culturally responsive
teaching and learning. These activities can help educators develop a deeper
understanding of cultural differences and become more effective in creating a
culturally responsive classroom. In the following, we will discuss three activities and
handouts (tables 1, 2) that can be used to promote culturally responsive teaching
practices in language education.
Activity 1: Exploring Personal Cultural Values
Objective: To reflect on one's personal cultural values and explore how they can influence
teaching practices
157
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
Instructions:
1.
In pairs or small groups, discuss and share your personal cultural values.
2.
Reflect on how these values may impact your teaching practices, including your choice of
teaching materials, classroom management, and student interactions.
Discuss ways to leverage your personal cultural values to create a culturally responsive classroom
environment.
Activity 2: Adapting Teaching Materials for Cultural Diversity
Objective: To practice adapting teaching materials to reflect cultural diversity
Instructions:
1.
In pairs or small groups, select a teaching material, such as a textbook or lesson plan.
2.
Analyze the material and identify any potential biases or cultural limitations.
3.
Brainstorm ways to adapt the material to reflect cultural diversity and promote inclusivity.
Share your adaptations with the class and discuss the effectiveness of these strategies.
Activity 3: Frameworks for Culturally Responsive Teaching
Objective: To explore frameworks for culturally responsive teaching and learning
Instructions:
1.
In pairs or small groups, research and discuss different frameworks for culturally responsive
teaching, such as the Gloria Ladson-Billings' Culturally Relevant Pedagogy or Geneva Gay's
Culturally Responsive Teaching.
2.
Analyze the key principles and practices of each framework.
Share your findings with the class and discuss the potential benefits and limitations of each
framework in promoting culturally responsive teaching and learning.
Table 1. Activities to promote culturally responsive teaching practices
The first activity is designed to help teachers reflect on their personal cultural
values and how they may impact their teaching practices. By discussing and sharing
their cultural values with others, teachers can become more aware of how their own
cultural background may influence their teaching methods, classroom management,
and student interactions. This activity also provides an opportunity for teachers to
discuss ways to leverage their cultural values to create a more culturally responsive
classroom environment.
Activity 2 is designed to help teachers reflect on their personal cultural values
and how they may impact their teaching practices. By discussing and sharing their
cultural values with others, teachers can become more aware of how their own cultural
background may influence their teaching methods, classroom management, and
student interactions. This activity also provides an opportunity for teachers to discuss
ways to leverage their cultural values to create a more culturally responsive classroom
environment.
The last activity is designed to help teachers reflect on their personal cultural
values and how they may impact their teaching practices. By discussing and sharing
their cultural values with others, teachers can become more aware of how their own
158
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
cultural background may influence their teaching methods, classroom management,
and student interactions. This activity also provides an opportunity for teachers to
discuss ways to leverage their cultural values to create a more culturally responsive
classroom environment.
Handout 1: Gloria Ladson-Billings' Culturally Relevant Pedagogy
Read the following scenario:
You are an English teacher in a diverse classroom with students from various cultural
backgrounds. You want to create a lesson that is culturally responsive and engaging for all
students. How would you apply the principles of culturally relevant pedagogy in your lesson
planning?
Answer the following questions:
1.
How would you incorporate the cultural backgrounds of your students in your lesson plan?
2.
How would you incorporate student interests and experiences into your lesson plan?
How would you create a safe and respectful classroom environment that values cultural diversity?
Handout 2: Geneva Gay's Culturally Responsive Teaching
Read the following scenario:
You are an English teacher in a diverse classroom with students from various cultural
backgrounds. You want to create a lesson that is culturally responsive and engages all students in
learning. How would you apply the principles of culturally responsive teaching in your lesson
planning?
Answer the following questions:
1.
How would you incorporate culturally relevant materials into your lesson plan?
2.
How would you promote positive cultural interactions among students?
How would you use teaching strategies that reflect diverse learning styles and cultural values?
Handout 3: James Banks' Multicultural Education
Read the following scenario:
You are an English teacher in a diverse classroom with students from various cultural
backgrounds. You want to create a lesson that is inclusive of all students' cultural experiences and
backgrounds. How would you apply the principles of multicultural education in your lesson
planning?
Answer the following questions:
1.
How would you incorporate diverse perspectives and experiences in your lesson plan?
2.
How would you challenge stereotypes and biases in your teaching?
How would you promote critical thinking and self-reflection among students regarding their own
cultural identities?
Table 2. Sample handouts to promote culturally responsive teaching practices
Handout 1 is based on Gloria Ladson-Billings' Culturally Relevant Pedagogy,
which emphasizes the importance of acknowledging and valuing the cultural
backgrounds and experiences of students. The handout presents a scenario where an
English teacher is planning a lesson for a diverse classroom and asks participants to
apply the principles of culturally relevant pedagogy in their lesson planning. The
159
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
questions in the handout prompt participants to think about how they can incorporate
their students' cultural backgrounds, interests, and experiences into the lesson plan, and
how they can create a safe and respectful classroom environment that values cultural
diversity. This handout encourages teachers to be more intentional and thoughtful in
their lesson planning and to consider how their teaching practices can promote cultural
responsiveness and inclusivity.
The second handout is based on Geneva Gay's Culturally Responsive Teaching,
which focuses on using culturally relevant materials and teaching strategies that reflect
the diverse learning styles and cultural values of students. The handout presents a
scenario where an English teacher is planning a lesson for a diverse classroom and asks
participants to apply the principles of culturally responsive teaching in their lesson
planning. The questions in the handout prompt participants to think about how they can
incorporate culturally relevant materials, promote positive cultural interactions among
students, and use teaching strategies that reflect diverse learning styles and cultural
values. This handout encourages teachers to be more intentional and thoughtful in their
lesson planning and to consider how their teaching practices can promote cultural
responsiveness and inclusivity.
The next handout is based on James Banks' Multicultural Education, which
emphasizes the importance of incorporating diverse perspectives and experiences in
teaching and challenging stereotypes and biases in the classroom. The handout presents
a scenario where an English teacher is planning a lesson for a diverse classroom and
asks participants to apply the principles of multicultural education in their lesson
planning. The questions in the handout prompt participants to think about how they can
incorporate diverse perspectives and experiences in their lesson plan, challenge
stereotypes and biases in their teaching, and promote critical thinking and self-
reflection among students regarding their own cultural identities. This handout
encourages teachers to be more intentional and thoughtful in their lesson planning and
to consider how their teaching practices can promote cultural responsiveness and
inclusivity.
Overall, these handouts provide concrete examples and scenarios that prompt
participants to apply the principles and frameworks of culturally responsive teaching
in their own lesson planning. They encourage teachers to think critically about their
teaching practices and consider how they can create a more culturally responsive and
inclusive classroom environment.
Discussion
As an English language teacher, it is essential to adapt curriculum and teaching
materials to reflect cultural diversity to meet the needs and experiences of diverse
160
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
learners. We can analyze some strategies for adapting curriculum and teaching
materials to reflect cultural diversity below:
1.
Evaluate and revise curriculum and materials
Evaluate your current curriculum and teaching materials and revise them to
ensure that they reflect cultural diversity. This includes incorporating diverse
perspectives, experiences, and cultural backgrounds into the materials.
2.
Use culturally relevant examples and materials
Use culturally relevant examples and materials that are familiar to students and
represent their cultural backgrounds. This can include using literature, films, and music
from diverse cultures.
3.
Provide opportunities for student voice and choice
Provide opportunities for student voice and choice in the curriculum and
materials. This can include allowing students to choose topics or materials that reflect
their cultural interests and experiences.
4.
Incorporate culturally responsive teaching strategies
Incorporate culturally responsive teaching strategies, such as building
relationships with students, using cooperative learning, and providing a safe and
respectful classroom environment.
5.
Collaborate with colleagues and community members
Collaborate with colleagues and community members to ensure that the
curriculum and materials reflect cultural diversity and are appropriate for diverse
learners.
By adapting curriculum and teaching materials to reflect cultural diversity,
English language teachers can create a learning environment that values and respects
diverse learners and their experiences.
By incorporating culturally responsive frameworks and practices, language
teachers can create a classroom environment that is inclusive, engaging, and
empowering for all students. In this activity, we will explore some examples of
culturally responsive teaching practices in English language teaching and discuss how
they align with culturally responsive frameworks:
1.
Using authentic materials:
Instead of relying solely on textbooks, use real-
world materials such as news articles, songs, and videos that reflect the diverse cultures
and perspectives of your students.
2.
Incorporating student voices:
Allow students to share their own
experiences, perspectives, and cultural practices in class discussions, presentations, and
assignments.
161
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
3.
Incorporating cultural references:
Introduce and incorporate cultural
references and examples that are familiar to your students to make the learning
experience more relatable and engaging.
4.
Encouraging collaboration:
Foster collaboration among students from
diverse cultural backgrounds to promote understanding and respect for one another's
perspectives and experiences.
5.
Providing feedback and support:
Provide feedback and support that is
culturally sensitive and responsive, taking into account the cultural norms and
expectations of your students.
After providing these examples, a teacher may ask students to work in pairs or
small groups to analyze and discuss how these practices align with culturally
responsive frameworks. A teacher should encourage them to think about how these
practices promote inclusivity, respect, and cultural diversity in the classroom. Then,
facilitating a whole-class discussion on the challenges and strategies for implementing
culturally responsive teaching practices in language teaching is important. The teacher
may ask students to share their own experiences and insights on how they have
overcome challenges in promoting cultural responsiveness in their classrooms.
Together, they should discuss potential strategies for overcoming these challenges and
promoting culturally responsive teaching practices in language teaching.
Conclusion
In this paper, we discussed the concept of culturally responsive teaching and
learning. We explored frameworks for culturally responsive teaching, such as Gloria
Ladson-Billings’ culturally relevant pedagogy, Geneva Gay's culturally responsive
teaching, and James Banks' multicultural education. We also discussed strategies for
adapting curriculum and teaching materials to reflect cultural diversity, and analyzed
examples of culturally responsive teaching practices in English language teaching.
Through this research, we think we achieved the learning outcome of
understanding the concept of culturally responsive teaching and learning. We learned
that culturally responsive teaching and learning involves recognizing and valuing the
cultural diversity of students, incorporating diverse perspectives and experiences into
teaching, and creating a safe and respectful classroom environment that promotes
positive cultural interactions.
References:
1.
Chen, G. M., & Starosta, W. J. (2000). The development and validation of the
intercultural sensitivity scale. Human Communication, 3(1), 1-15.
2.
Gay, G. (2000). Culturally responsive teaching: Theory, research, and practice.
Teachers College Press.
162
TADBIRKORLIK VA PEDAGOGIKA. ILMIY-USLUBIY JURNAL. ISSN: 2181-2659. [1/2023].
3.
Gudykunst, W. B., & Kim, Y. Y. (1997). Communicating with strangers: An
approach to intercultural communication. McGraw-Hill.
4.
Jandt, F. E. (2016). An introduction to intercultural communication: Identities in a
global community. Sage Publications.
5.
Ladson-Billings, G. (1995). Toward a theory of culturally relevant pedagogy.
American Educational Research Journal, 32(3), 465-491.
6.
Makhmudov, K. (2020). Ways of forming intercultural communication in foreign
language teaching. Science and Education, 1(4), 84-89.
7.
Makhmudov, K. (2021). Learning a Target Language within its Culture as an
Effective Method. Academic research in educational sciences, 2(CSPI conference
1), 620-623.
8.
Makhmudov, K. (2022). The Role, Competences and Methods of a Teacher in
Learner's Forming Intercultural Communication. International Journal of Innovative
Research in Science, Engineering and Technology, 11(3), 2688-2691.
9.
Nieto, S. (2013). Language, culture, and teaching: Critical perspectives. Routledge.
10.
Ting-Toomey, S. (2018). Identity negotiation theory: Crossing cultural boundaries.
Cambridge University Press.
